Tom Lane wrote: > Josh Berkus <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > > 3) Dann is proposing not just a feature but sweeping changes to the way our > > commmunity works, despite having been a member of this community for about 3 > > weeks total. > > In Dann's defense, I didn't think I heard him proposing that we get rid > of our existing testing methods, but rather that we see if we can't > supplement them with something more formal. This strikes me as a > perfectly reasonable proposal. However, he hasn't succeeded in > convincing anyone else to put their time into it (for reasons that > are also perfectly reasonable, namely that we find that our existing > methods do pretty well, and we don't have the manpower to create a large > formal testing structure ... even if we thought it would repay the effort, > which many of us doubt). So it's his itch to scratch, or not. > > Unless there's something more profitable to be said on the subject, > could we drop the thread?
One thing that came out of the thread is the fact that many people who use PostgreSQL do testing in many different ways, and that much of the stability of PostgreSQL can be attributed to that. It occurs to me that there may be (perhaps) a lot of duplication of effort there that could be reduced a bit. So...would it make sense to create a gborg project to which people who have written their own test suites can contribute whatever code and data they feel comfortable releasing? As a gborg project, it would be separate from the main PG distribution and would thus have no impact on the build process or anything like that. But at the same time, if there are any ideas on testing that people have had, they could be shared with others through that mechanism. And any tests which prove to be particularly useful could make their way into the PG distribution if people here wish. Of course, like anything else this could be a bad (or perhaps redundant) idea. :-) -- Kevin Brown [EMAIL PROTECTED] ---------------------------(end of broadcast)--------------------------- TIP 6: Have you searched our list archives? http://archives.postgresql.org