Dear Dr. Solovyov, dear all,

On Sat, 19 Feb 2005 06:57:02 -0800 (PST), Leonid Solovyov wrote:

>> We do not recomment this method in other cases than such with
>> complicated structured background, as demonstrated in the above
>> article.
>> R values and random errors of the results become much larger.
>
>I can not agree with these statements. DDM is advantageous not only in
>cases of complex background, but also for "normal" data where the
>background may be seemingly simple. Even when the background line is
>apparently flat it normally has some oscillations which may be
>invisible due to the peak overlapping. The cases when the background
>can be correctly modeled by the generally applied empirical functions
>are very rare (if exist at all), and the systematic errors introduced
>by the inadequate background approximations always limit the refinement
>accuracy. The example of Pd(NH3)4(C2O4) in the above article (J. Appl.
>Cryst. 37 (2004), pp. 743-749) demonstrates exactly this case of DDM
>application to "normal" data. This example is included into the DDM
>program package (http://krsk.info/icct/en/cont/persons/sol/ddm.html)
>and I already have many more.
>As to DDM-R values and random errors, if DDM is properly applied the
>random errors are normally similar or lower that those with Rietveld
>refinement. DDM-R values are calculated differently (involving
>derivatives) and can not be directly compared with Rietveld R values
>(which are often calculated even without the background subtraction).
>
>Another recommendation:
>> If you wish to use this method, we recommend you should
>> collect millions of counts for a single pattern.
>
>is absolutely not valid. DDM works perfectly well with an ordinary
>powder pattern collected on a laboratory diffractometer with a step of
>0.02 degrees 2theta and counting time 3-5 seconds per point (see the
>examples in the DDM package).
>
>Finally, my recommendation is: always try using DDM instead of Rietveld
>refinement even when the background seems to be simple.

We cannot follow this suggestion. We have checked about 10
examples of (partially complicated, 10 phases) quant analysis.
Of course, the R values are larger, for example:
Rietveld: Rexp=6%  Rwp 8%
DDM:      Rexp=25% Rwp 30%
The errors following statistical error propagation are somewhat
larger than for normal Rietveld. But, trying standard
mixtures with known content, the differences between known
and measured weight contents are at least twice larger.
In many cases, convergence was much slower. Plus the
acceptance ranges of the lattice parameters (we did not try
structure refinement) was much smaller.

Maybe, DDM is of some advantage in structure refinement.
In quant analysis, we cannot recomment DDM, at least
with BGMNs fundamental parameter profiles. Maybe, it
has some advantages for older Rietveld programs with
classical UVW profile shapes. As we have observed,
the DDM method is insensitive for wrong "tails" on the
peaks, they become background. These tails are a problem 
with common UVW etc. profile shapes in Rietveld analysis.

Regards

Joerg Bergmann
*** This EComStation system uptime is 0 days 18 hours ***

Reply via email to