> with DDM the deviations between known and estimated content
> are twice larger compared to Rietveld.

In this case the problem might be not in the DDM method, but in its
particular realization in BGMN. The most probable reason is the minimal
convolution intervals used. For noisy data the interval choice is
essential.

> I worry about "filtering out" some below-1%-phases while using DDM,
> so I decided to use only 5 data points. In structure refinement,
> you have always lots of intense peaks. Having in mind quant
> analysis, I have decided to use 5 data points only (an old
> rule says "at lest 5 data points on the peak width at half
> maximum", which corresponds to L. Solovjov's article). Using the
> adaptive method as described by L. Solovjov, minor phases (with 
> partially low symmetry) may be "filtered out". They could be 
> estimated wrong: Large ranges with lots of minor peaks may
> be detected as "linear" or "quadratic" and covered with only one
> single large range with a lot of data points.

Choosing wider intervals for certain regions does not mean "filtering
out". On contrary, the data-points of wider intervals are multiply
included into the minimization function and thus have higher weights.
This is one of the advantages of the adaptive interval choice for noisy
data.
In structural analysis the situation is similar. If I use minimal fixed
convolution intervals I can obtain satisfactory results only for
"nearly ideal" data with small noise and well resolved peaks. For
"real" noisy and overlapped patterns wider and adaptive intervals
should be applied.

Best wishes,
Leonid



__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam?  Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around 
http://mail.yahoo.com 

Reply via email to