Robin Bowes;273811 Wrote: > Listener wrote:[color=blue] > > Robin Bowes;273719 Wrote: [color=green] > > I made a statement that is correct in the vast majority of cases. You > pointing out one or two exceptions doesn't alter the validity of my > statement. > ... > There *is* no logic to your posts. You're not wrong - it's just your > viewpoint. I disagree with you. >
> I made a statement that is correct in the vast majority of > cases. You pointing out one or two exceptions doesn't alter > the validity of my statement. Your original statement was wrong. I pointed that out. You keep revising your criteria to avoid admitting that you were wrong. I found one s/w player that works for me. That's certainly a "viable" solution for me. I'm using Composer and Artist Tags on an 80GB iPod. That's "viable" for me. I identified Foobar as another player that can use the tags we need and I described a file folder browsing approach for portable players. More "viable" approaches. That isn't opinion. I wrote that your original statement was wrong and that your sweeping conclusion was wrong using my own experience. You have revised "all" to "vast majority" but that doesn't support your original conclusion. Having even one alternative makes an approach "viable." > The only viable way to make classical music work with > most players on the market today is to work within the > limitations of the Track/Album/Artist paradigm. So if you find those limitations to be important, look for the players that work the way you want to. That is a natural reaction if you know that better alternatives exist. Talking about the issues and identifying players that are less limited is a way to make progress. > You are obviously on the ideological side of the argument. > Fine. Good luck to you. Can you state your own opinion without using inaccurate, dismissive language? > Believe me, I'd like nothing more than a better way of > handling classical music, but I firmly believe that > stepping outside Track/Album/Artist is a waste of time > because that excludes 99% of music players. Fine. Keep your opinion. You have already tried to cram it down everyone else's throat. Just stop trying to convince everyone else to stop trying to make progress. Bill -- Listener ------------------------------------------------------------------------ Listener's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=2508 View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=43851 _______________________________________________ ripping mailing list [email protected] http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/ripping
