>> It is, if you want to have a compilation album with an Album Artist tag. >really? b/c i do exactly that, and works great for me. > No you don't. Maybe you misread what I was saying.
>show me the standards body that agrees with you, where it says setting >an AA tag on a comp is "incorrect." What are you on about? This has nothing to do with standards. And I am not saying that having an AA tag on a comp is incorrect - far from it, I do that myself in a few cases. You cannot have an album reported in SBS as a compilation album with an album artist tag without setting both a compilation tag and an album artist tag. Unless you are hacking the code/database content??? >conversely, i can show you several >apps and tagging sources, like gracenote, amg, itunes, wmp, winamp, etc >that set an AA tag on everything, comp or not. thats authority in >practice at the very least. > Irrelevant. >just b/c SBS doesn't want AA tags for comps doesn't mean SBS is right >or an authority by which things can be said to be correct or incorrect. > SBS does support AA tags on compilations. SBS has as much right or authority to handle tags as any other app. If you see other apps as having more authority, then how much more popular does SBS have to become before you seeing it having more authority? All irrelevant anyway. I am saying what SBS currently does - what a user must do if they want compilations. _______________________________________________ ripping mailing list [email protected] http://lists.slimdevices.com/mailman/listinfo/ripping
