I fully expect that the collector side of the hobby will continue to be a 
driving force - and the varied Heritage schemes are made-to-order for that. We 
can hope that they make enough additional sales to keep the scale features 
going in the SHS line (and Flyonel as well), but I do not think that enough 
purely scale buyers will magically appear to float the line without the 
collectors. 

Maybe some day in the future a newer group of S gaugers will abandon 
compatibility with ca 1950 Flyer, but not next year or the year after. I'm sure 
MTH also hopes that some O gauge collectors will become interested  enough to 
add S to their collections as well.

Pieter E. Roos

--- On Fri, 7/6/12, [email protected] <[email protected]> wrote:







>   The fact that they are promoting these vanity schemes makes me
think
> they don't understand the scale model railroad market as
well as they do
> the toy train /collector market.
>  
Scale modelers want to model the typical, not the unique. If NS has a
> 100 diesels in plain black for every 1 loco in heritage scheme
the
> modern NS scale modeler is not gonna run out and buy a
heritage loco.
> Well, these are prototype schemes. The
fact that Lionel is doing scale-wheeled covered hoppers in combination
with a variety of bizarro fantasy paint jobs indicates that they are the
ones who really don't get the scale market. I've ordered one of the gray
cars.Stan Stokrocki




Reply via email to