Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-05 Thread Taran Rampersad
Subbiah Arunachalam wrote: > Steve Eskow suggests that governments buy very large numbers of > computers (simputers, Mobilis or the Negroponte equivalent) and give > them away to telecentres nation wide. But a telecentre is not just the > computing equipment. It is much more, very much more. It in

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-02 Thread Joseph Beckmann
D] On Behalf Of Subbiah Arunachalam Sent: Wednesday, June 01, 2005 4:25 AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; The Digital Divide Network discussion group Subject: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer Steve Eskow suggests that governments buy very large numbers of computers (simputers, Mobilis or the Negroponte

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-01 Thread Taran Rampersad
[Note to moderation: Responding to an email that did have me cc'd, and which I am not CC'ing anyone on. But my response is one line, and is the end of my discussion on this particular thread.] After the Axial Age, everyone became an expert. Tom Abeles wrote: > Hi Taran > > the simputer is mere

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-01 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Taran Rampersad comments on this: >The approach Jon Hall describes below makes much sense: there are many >governments around the world that might well consider it.>> > This way: > > <> It is important to do what Taran has done here: to make "affordability" a central issue in deciding on how bes

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-01 Thread Subbiah Arunachalam
discussion group" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Tuesday, May 31, 2005 9:24 PM Subject: RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer Taran Rampersad, presently in Panama City, writes: <> There is no necessary conflict between the "public" and the "private." Those who can affo

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-01 Thread Taran Rampersad
Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: >The approach Jon Hall describes below makes much sense: there are many >governments around the world that might well consider it. > >Steve Eskow > > Assuming that they can afford it. -- Taran Rampersad Presently in: Panama City, Panama [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://www.know

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-06-01 Thread Subbiah Arunachalam
far more difficult job. Arun [Subbiah Arunachalam] - Original Message - From: "Dr. Steve Eskow" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> To: "The Digital Divide Network discussion group" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Wednesday, June 01, 2005 12:08 AM Subject: RE: [DDN] Upda

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Taran Rampersad
John Hibbs wrote: > At 10:02 AM -0700 5/29/05, Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: > >> If the Simputer is a superior product, and mass producing it will >> dramatically lower its price, the Simputer firm might emulate >> Negroponte and >> insist on mass orders. > > > "Insist"? How? > > How much good would it

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Taran Rampersad
Todd Seal wrote: > Ah, yes! The smart card! That's what I'm thinking of when I think of > sitting at a public computer for personal use. > > What's the danger, though, in losing one of those cards? Think of how > easy it is to lose a file on your computer. Isn't that problem > compounded when you

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Jon maddog Hall
[EMAIL PROTECTED] said: > Marvelous. The Simputer plus the idea of Public Computing plus promoting the > idea of governments purchasing a million or more at one time and seeing to > their distribution and we have a strategy for an attack on the digital divide > that might make a difference. The

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Taran Rampersad
Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: > Marvelous. The Simputer plus the idea of Public Computing plus promoting >the idea of governments purchasing a million or more at one time and seeing >to their distribution and we have a strategy for an attack on the digital >divide that might make a difference. > > I'm

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
AM To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]; The Digital Divide Network discussion group Cc: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Subject: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer [EMAIL PROTECTED] said: > Marvelous. The Simputer plus the idea of Public Computing plus promoting the > idea of governments purchasing a million or more

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Of Tom Abeles Sent: Tuesday, May 31, 2005 8:03 AM To: The Digital Divide Network discussion group; John Hibbs Subject: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer There is an essay with a title, something to the effect, "The Fear of God and the Need to Acquire" where there is a line, paraphrased,

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Mr. John Hibbs writes: dramatically lower its price, the Simputer firm might emulate Negroponte and >insist on mass orders.>> "Insist"? How?>> As I understand the Negroponte idea, by taking no orders for less than a million o

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Taran Rampersad
Tom Abeles wrote: > There is an essay with a title, something to the effect, "The Fear of > God and the Need to Acquire" where there is a line, paraphrased, which > says that there is a problem when the only way a person can show love > for his/her spouse is to go to bed with them or BUY them some

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Taran Rampersad, presently in Panama City, writes: <> There is no necessary conflict between the "public" and the "private." Those who can afford private automobiles should be allowed to have them, until the world's pollution problem becomes so great that we have to consider limiting that right.

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Tom Abeles
There is an essay with a title, something to the effect, "The Fear of God and the Need to Acquire" where there is a line, paraphrased, which says that there is a problem when the only way a person can show love for his/her spouse is to go to bed with them or BUY them something. One must realiz

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Todd Seal writes about the perils of "the smart card": <> If the public computer is in a church, or library, or office, the cards can be kept there rather than taken home. And note how easily we overlook the difficulties associated with the personal computer. When 20 people each own a person

[DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-31 Thread John Hibbs
At 10:02 AM -0700 5/29/05, Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: If the Simputer is a superior product, and mass producing it will dramatically lower its price, the Simputer firm might emulate Negroponte and insist on mass orders. "Insist"? How? How much good would it do to set a date ceartain - as Earth Da

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-30 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Jayne Cravens writes: <> In your previous incarnation at the UN, and since, you've taught many of us a great deal, Jayne. Turn about is fair play. Steve Eskow [EMAIL PROTECTED] ___ DIGITALDIVIDE mailing list DIGITALDIVIDE@mailman.edc.org http://ma

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-30 Thread Todd Seal
Ah, yes! The smart card! That's what I'm thinking of when I think of sitting at a public computer for personal use. What's the danger, though, in losing one of those cards? Think of how easy it is to lose a file on your computer. Isn't that problem compounded when you have a card that can get

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-30 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Daniel Escasa writes: <> Marvelous. The Simputer plus the idea of Public Computing plus promoting the idea of governments purchasing a million or more at one time and seeing to their distribution and we have a strategy for an attack on the digital divide that might make a difference. Steve E

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer - Notebook vs Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread Jon maddog Hall
Hi, I have followed the conversation so far, and Taran has made some good points about the Simputer vs a notebook. There are other issues that a lot of people do not think about in the design of a computer system for developing nations. Replacement parts: One of the things that often breaks in

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread Daniel O. Escasa
Sabi ni bryan noong Sat, 28 May 2005 13:36:53 +0800: > $480??? And i thought the simputer was supposed to help bring computers > to all levels of society. At that cost it wont get any farther than the > current PC penetration and with so many competitors they can forget doing > mass production runs

Re: [SPAM] Re: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread Dr. Bill Peet
work discussion group" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Sent: Saturday, May 28, 2005 2:08 PM Subject: [SPAM] Re: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer > I want to point out, just in case it has not been mentioned by Taran or > > others, that the initial Simputer had a text-to-speech synthes

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
Taran Rampersad writes: >>..Toss in the fact that only 50,000 [Simputers] were produced compared to the millions of components built by commercial entities. Don't believe me? Ask Negroponte why it takes a minimum order of 1 *million* PCs to meet the $100 laptop which the MIT Media Lab is looki

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread J Cravens
I just wanted to say that I find this back and forth about Simputer fantastic. Thank you to everyone who is contributing/debating. I'm learning so much. -- <><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><><> Jayne Cravens Bonn, Germany Services for Mission-Based Orgs www.coyotecommunications.com TECH4IMPACT

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-29 Thread Daniel O. Escasa
Sabi ni maddog noong Fri, 27 May 2005 10:57:58 -0400: > One of the things that interests me about the Simputer is the inclusion > of > two USB ports. Thus hooked to a power supply and a USB disk drive, USB > keyboard > and USB mouse you might be able to have a fairly interesting "desktop" > (alth

Re: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-28 Thread Amos Anyimadu
I want to point out, just in case it has not been mentioned by Taran or > others, that the initial Simputer had a text-to-speech synthesizer built > into it for several Indian languages, which made it possible for > non-literate users to use the computer to 'read' text files written in > their Ar

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-28 Thread Taran Rampersad
Uddami Computer Training Centre wrote: >$480??? And i thought the simputer was supposed to help bring computers to all >levels of society. At that cost it wont get any farther than the current PC >penetration and with so many competitors they can forget doing mass production >runs. > >bryan fo

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-28 Thread Taran Rampersad
Dr. Bill Peet wrote: >Hello All, > >I've been lurking for several years, but this item has pulled me out of >hiding. > >I want to point out, just in case it has not been mentioned by Taran or >others, that the initial Simputer had a text-to-speech synthesizer built >into it for several Indian lang

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-28 Thread Uddami Computer Training Centre
PROTECTED] http://www.uddami.org Original Message -- Message: 11 Date: Thu, 26 May 2005 22:00:30 -0500 From: Taran Rampersad <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> Subject: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer To: The Digital Divide Network discussion group <[EMAIL PROTECTED]

Re: Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-28 Thread Dr. Bill Peet
PROTECTED]> Sent: Thursday, May 26, 2005 11:00 PM Subject: [SPAM] Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer > Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: > > >Taran, > > > >I ask you this publicly rather than privately, since others on this DDN list > >may have the same question. > > > &g

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-27 Thread Jon maddog Hall
Taran, One of the things that interests me about the Simputer is the inclusion of two USB ports. Thus hooked to a power supply and a USB disk drive, USB keyboard and USB mouse you might be able to have a fairly interesting "desktop" (although with a fairly small screen). Lots of "PDAs" do not ha

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-27 Thread Taran Rampersad
Jon maddog Hall wrote: >Taran, > >One of the things that interests me about the Simputer is the inclusion of >two USB ports. Thus hooked to a power supply and a USB disk drive, USB >keyboard >and USB mouse you might be able to have a fairly interesting "desktop" >(although with a fairly small sc

RE: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-27 Thread Dr. Steve Eskow
arranty3 and At-Home Service4 Steve Eskow [EMAIL PROTECTED] -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] Behalf Of Taran Rampersad Sent: Thursday, May 26, 2005 10:31 AM To: The Digital Divide Network discussion group Subject: [DDN] Update on the Simputer I'v

Re: [DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-27 Thread Taran Rampersad
Dr. Steve Eskow wrote: >Taran, > >I ask you this publicly rather than privately, since others on this DDN list >may have the same question. > >How man US dollars does a "high end" Amida Simputer cost? > > Right now? $480. With an initial run of 50,000 manufactured, it's hard to compete with a De

[DDN] Update on the Simputer

2005-05-26 Thread Taran Rampersad
I've made contact with Amida Simputer - I will be purchasing a high end Simputer at the beginning of June, and having it sent to me in Panama. This is an out of pocket expense for me, but I'm putting my money where my mouth is (now that I have the money coming in) and will be taking it with me to G