RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-21 Thread Andrew Bowden
Brian Butterworth wrote: I thought we were talking about FreeVIEW HD. Freesat is named the same, Freesat+ is the PVR, Freesat HD is the HD service, Freesat+ HD is the PVR with HD We were talking about Freeview, however if it follows the same conventions as Freesat then Freeview+ can

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-21 Thread Ant Miller
On a side bar, the estimable @nevali is doing lovely work on an IPTV interface, incluing a far nicer Freeview logo! http://emberapp.com/nevali/images/services-menu a On Mon, Sep 21, 2009 at 9:22 AM, Andrew Bowden andrew.bow...@bbc.co.uk wrote: Brian Butterworth wrote: I thought we were

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-21 Thread Rhys Jones
September 30th? Oh no, not again. This all means I'll have had to retune my mother's TV and Freeview DVD recorder no fewer than four times within five weeks. She lives within the Carmel transmitter area, for which the dates were/are: August 26th (DSO1) September 9th (S4C moved to Mux B,

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-19 Thread Brian Butterworth
What tosh. 2009/9/18 Tom Morris bbtommor...@gmail.com On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 18:19, Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv wrote: BUT The plus denotes a PVR and two letter denote HD There's no wonder 8% of the public think the TVL pays for ITV Well, we've got: * Internet *

[backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Briefly, DVB-T2 uses MPEG4 delivered in a 30Mbps (compare 18Mbps and 24Mps) multiplex using 256QAM (compared with 16QAM and 64QAM) with LDPC/BCH error correction (not FEC) and 32k carriers (compare 2k and 8k). http://www.ukfree.tv/fullstory.php?storyid=1107051377 Basically, this is not a

[backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Frankie Roberto
2009/9/17 Brendan Quinn brendan.qu...@bbc.co.uk Alan wrote: I assume my topfield HD will be out of date with these proposed changes? Ant replied: You'll need to retune, but the services you currently get on Freeview should still be available. Think of Freeview + as an optional

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Andrew Bowden
Cynically, who wants to guess what proportion of HD Ready TV owners a) think they're already watching HD content on Freeview Probably a similar amount to those who have boxes set to 4:3 centre cut out, which is then stretched to 16:9 by their TV :( - Sent via the backstage.bbc.co.uk

Re: [backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Simon Thompson
30 Mbps is a bit of a low estimate for T2. Wikipedia suggests at least 35. 2009/9/18 Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv Briefly, DVB-T2 uses MPEG4 delivered in a 30Mbps (compare 18Mbps and 24Mps) multiplex using 256QAM (compared with 16QAM and 64QAM) with LDPC/BCH error correction (not

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Freeview+ is the name of the Freeview PVR/DVR. Freeview HD will be called, Freeview HD. 2009/9/17 Ant Miller ant.mil...@gmail.com Freeview and freeview+ (as the DVB-T2 carried HD mux is to be called) will exist in parallel- the number of muxes will drop from 6 to 5, one will go to DVB-t2,

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Please see http://www.ukfree.tv/fullstory.php?storyid=1107051316 http://www.ukfree.tv/fullstory.php?storyid=1107051316and http://www.ukfree.tv/fullstory.php?storyid=1107051377 http://www.ukfree.tv/fullstory.php?storyid=1107051377and (for dates)

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Multiplex B aka PSB3 aka BBCB is not VACATED by the BBC, BBC FTV Ltd still owns the multiplex. It is being used for Freeview HD carrying three (soon four) public service HD channels. 2009/9/17 Simon Thompson st...@zepler.net Ofcom is going to use Multiplex B (vacated by the BBC) to provide

Re: [backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Wikipedia is wrong (that's a suprise). The carrying capacity is 30Mbps, according to the specification. 2009/9/18 Simon Thompson st...@zepler.net 30 Mbps is a bit of a low estimate for T2. Wikipedia suggests at least 35. 2009/9/18 Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv Briefly, DVB-T2

Re: [backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Phil Lewis
On Fri, 2009-09-18 at 09:54 +0100, Frankie Roberto wrote: ... If only I could stream BBC iPlayer direct to my TV via my Apple TV box, I wouldn't really ever need a Freeview HD box. I have created an iPlayer streaming proxy for Unix/Linux/OSX/Win32 to do just this. Not actually tried it with an

Re: [backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Simon Thompson
Last time I checked the Blue book it didn't mention bitrates: http://www.dvb.org/technology/standards/a122r1.tm3980r7.DVB-T2.pdf And the last time I saw the chairman of the DVB-T2 technical module speaking he mentioned 36 Mbps: 2009/9/18 Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv Wikipedia is

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Simon Thompson
Poor choice of words by me. Multiplex B is having the SD channels removed from it and is being converted to MPEG4 part 10 and DVB-T2 to allow HD channels to be transmitted. 2009/9/18 Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv Multiplex B aka PSB3 aka BBCB is not VACATED by the BBC, BBC FTV Ltd

Re: [backstage] Re: Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Simon, I might be wrong, but I'm sure that when you put in the parameters that are being used in the UK for DVB-T2 you get 30Mbps of post-error corrected data. It's quite possible that they have changed the parameters to provide 36Mbps, but my understanding was that 30Mbps is what you will get to

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Ant Miller
Yup, my bad. In my defense, it's all a bit complex, and the slides I saw didn't make the distinction clear. Still and all, to get back to the original thread subject, I've seen no sign of a broadcast flag or even CPCM being shoe horned into either the DSO or HD roll out. a On Fri, Sep 18, 2009

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
It's not really being converted. The Freeview HD services are a cease and re-provide. After switch-over the multiplexes are known as BBCA, D3+4, BBCB, SDN, ARQA and ARQB or PSB1, PSB2, PSB3, COM4, COM5 and COM6 (plus the MEN mux in Manchester). 2009/9/18 Simon Thompson st...@zepler.net Poor

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 01:01, Mr I Forrester mail...@cubicgarden.comwrote: On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 22:04 +0100, Scot McSweeney-Roberts wrote: I think that there's going to be a lot of unhappy freeview HDTV owners wondering why the TV they have recently bought isn't picking up the new HD

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Once again, Freeview+ is the PVR, Freeview HD is the HD service 2009/9/18 Scot McSweeney-Roberts bbc_backst...@mcsweeney-roberts.co.uk On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 01:01, Mr I Forrester mail...@cubicgarden.comwrote: On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 22:04 +0100, Scot McSweeney-Roberts wrote: I think

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Gareth Davis
Brian Butterworth wrote: Once again, Freeview+ is the PVR, Freeview HD is the HD service As an aside, the two types of Freesat receiver we have in the office are marked Freesat HD and Freesat+. But the Freesat+ box does HD as well as PVR. -- Gareth Davis | Production Systems Specialist

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
I thought we were talking about FreeVIEW HD. Freesat is named the same, Freesat+ is the PVR, Freesat HD is the HD service, Freesat+ HD is the PVR with HD... 2009/9/18 Gareth Davis gareth.da...@bbc.co.uk Brian Butterworth wrote: Once again, Freeview+ is the PVR, Freeview HD is the HD

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Gareth Davis
Brian Butterworth wrote: I thought we were talking about FreeVIEW HD. Freesat is named the same, Freesat+ is the PVR, Freesat HD is the HD service, Freesat+ HD is the PVR with HD We were talking about Freeview, however if it follows the same conventions as Freesat then Freeview+ can mean HD

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
BUT The plus denotes a PVR and two letter denote HD There's no wonder 8% of the public think the TVL pays for ITV 2009/9/18 Gareth Davis gareth.da...@bbc.co.uk Brian Butterworth wrote: I thought we were talking about FreeVIEW HD. Freesat is named the same, Freesat+ is the PVR, Freesat

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Ant Miller
To be honest I saw a lot of confusing presentation of logos in the DVB-T2 presentation at IBC. It's a personal point but I happen to think the Freeview logo is an absolute dog of design, and all the + and HD tack ons are awful. Still waddo I know?! a On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 6:19 PM, Brian

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Brian Butterworth
Ant, I totally agree about the Freeview logo. When I was a kid you could get Cooper Black[1] in Boots The Chemist dry transfer lettering (poor man's Letraset). Everytime I see it I just think of the layouts I did at school using a typewriter (before the school has a printer) and Cooper Black.

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 15:54, Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tvwrote: Once again, Freeview+ is the PVR, Freeview HD is the HD service I know that, I was requoting Ant's minor slipup of using Freeview+ for FreeviewHD

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Tom Morris
On Fri, Sep 18, 2009 at 18:19, Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv wrote: BUT The plus denotes a PVR and two letter denote HD There's no wonder 8% of the public think the TVL pays for ITV Well, we've got: * Internet * Internet+ - lets you save files! * Internet HD - appears in high

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-18 Thread Christopher Woods
I totally agree about the Freeview logo. When I was a kid you could get Cooper Black[1] in Boots The Chemist dry transfer lettering (poor man's Letraset). Everytime I see it I just think of the layouts I did at school using a typewriter (before the school has a printer) and Cooper Black.

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Frankie Roberto
2009/9/16 Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv http://www.boingboing.net/2009/09/15/bbc-wants-to-put-drm.html BBC wants to put DRM on the TV Brits are forced to pay for It's worth noting that this applies ONLY to HD DTV (Freeview), which barely even exists yet. So don't throw away your

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Frankie Roberto
2009/9/17 Frankie Roberto fran...@frankieroberto.com It's worth noting that this applies ONLY to HD DTV (Freeview), which barely even exists yet. So don't throw away your Freeview boxes just yet. I can't see a switchover from Freeview to Freeview HD happening any time soon... This is some

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Christopher Woods
Moreover, you just *know* that within months of any broadcast flag implementation, the more creative technological tinkerers will have subverted the flag entirely using commonplace/free equipment and software. Like region coding, broadcast flags really are an exercise in stupidity and corporate

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Frankie Roberto
2009/9/17 Christopher Woods chris...@infinitus.co.uk Moreover, you just *know* that within months of any broadcast flag implementation, the more creative technological tinkerers will have subverted the flag entirely using commonplace/free equipment and software. Like region coding, broadcast

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Alun Rowe
Will we ever see HD freeview though? The bandwidth requirement would be enormous. On 17 Sep 2009, at 16:53, Frankie Roberto fran...@frankieroberto.com wrote: 2009/9/17 Christopher Woods chris...@infinitus.co.uk Moreover, you just *know* that within months of any broadcast flag

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Ant Miller
Freeview and freeview+ (as the DVB-T2 carried HD mux is to be called) will exist in parallel- the number of muxes will drop from 6 to 5, one will go to DVB-t2, the other 4 will up their capacity with a little tweak and reshuffled channels from the flipped mux will be shared around them. The New

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Simon Thompson
Ofcom is going to use Multiplex B (vacated by the BBC) to provide DVB-T2 HD services. First region on air is Granada later this year. 2009/9/17 Alun Rowe alun.r...@pentangle.co.uk Will we ever see HD freeview though? The bandwidth requirement would be enormous. On 17 Sep 2009, at 16:53,

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Gareth Davis
Ant Miller wrote: Freeview and freeview+ (as the DVB-T2 carried HD mux is to be called) will exist in parallel- the number of muxes will drop from 6 to 5, one will go to DVB-t2, the other 4 will up their capacity with a little tweak and reshuffled channels from the flipped mux will be

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Ant Miller
You'll need to retune, but the services you currently get on Freeview should still be available. Think of Freeview + as an optional upgrade. a On Thu, Sep 17, 2009 at 5:36 PM, Alun Rowe alun.r...@pentangle.co.uk wrote: I assume my topfield HD will be out of date with these proposed changes?

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Alun Rowe
I meant in terms of the HD element if they are changing the spec? If there is a decryption requirement I doubt the Topfield will have it? On 17 Sep 2009, at 17:52, Ant Miller ant.mil...@gmail.com wrote: You'll need to retune, but the services you currently get on Freeview should still be

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Ant Miller
I don't know the topfield box, but it's unlikely it can decode the new carrier mode. h.264 it might be able to handle, but it would be a surprise. So no, the HD will need a new box. Optional upgrade, not a free upgrade! Though the broadcast service will remain free to air. a On Thu, Sep 17,

Freeview HD vs existing HDMI upscaling freeview boxes (was RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?)

2009-09-17 Thread Brendan Quinn
Alan wrote: I assume my topfield HD will be out of date with these proposed changes? Ant replied: You'll need to retune, but the services you currently get on Freeview should still be available. Think of Freeview + as an optional upgrade. To which Alun wrote: I meant in terms of the HD

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Scot McSweeney-Roberts
On Thu, Sep 17, 2009 at 17:29, Ant Miller ant.mil...@gmail.com wrote: Keeping audiences happy as DSO happens and Freeview+ rolls out is a critical task, I think that there's going to be a lot of unhappy freeview HDTV owners wondering why the TV they have recently bought isn't picking up the

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Mr I Forrester
On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 22:04 +0100, Scot McSweeney-Roberts wrote: I think that there's going to be a lot of unhappy freeview HDTV owners wondering why the TV they have recently bought isn't picking up the new HD channels when they're launched (especially as the TV was probably sold as HD

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Christopher Woods
I think that there's going to be a lot of unhappy freeview HDTV owners wondering why the TV they have recently bought isn't picking up the new HD channels when they're launched (especially as the TV was probably sold as HD Ready). Prime opportunity to flog another STB / CAM to correctly

RE: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Mr I Forrester
On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 15:50 +0100, Christopher Woods wrote: Moreover, you just *know* that within months of any broadcast flag implementation, the more creative technological tinkerers will have subverted the flag entirely using commonplace/free equipment and software. Like region coding,

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-17 Thread Nick Morrott
On 18/09/2009, Mr I Forrester mail...@cubicgarden.com wrote: On Thu, 2009-09-17 at 22:04 +0100, Scot McSweeney-Roberts wrote: I think that there's going to be a lot of unhappy freeview HDTV owners wondering why the TV they have recently bought isn't picking up the new HD channels

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-16 Thread Rupert Watson
At a guess it is the parties that paid large sums of money to acquire or create the content. Sent from my dog On 16 Sep 2009, at 07:52, Brian Butterworth briant...@freeview.tv wrote: I was going to post about this when I saw the original document, but I'm ashamed to say I didn't get

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-16 Thread Brian Butterworth
http://www.boingboing.net/2009/09/15/bbc-wants-to-put-drm.html BBC wants to put DRM on the TV Brits are forced to pay for 2009/9/16 Rupert Watson rup...@root6.com At a guess it is the parties that paid large sums of money to acquire or create the content. Ah, those lovely people at PACT.

Re: [backstage] License to Kill Innovation: the Broadcast Flag for UK Digital TV?

2009-09-16 Thread Tim Dobson
Rupert Watson wrote: At a guess it is the parties that paid large sums of money to acquire or create the content. Boingboing seemed to think it was a DRM consortium that had prompted the move. Sent from my dog Loving it, wish my dog could answer email for me! - Sent via the