[computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll results

2008-01-28 Thread Nick Wedd
Thanks to all those who voted for various aspects of how KGS Bot tournaments are run. I assume that everyone who meant to respond has now done so, and I declare the poll closed. I received ten responses. The result follow. (1.) Do we want to keep separate Formal and Open divisions? Keep

Re: [computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll results

2008-01-28 Thread David Doshay
You must have been tired ... Continue to use Absolute? Cheers, David On 28, Jan 2008, at 3:56 AM, Nick Wedd wrote: A majority for Absolute, a minority for byo-yomi, and no-one for Canadian. I shall continue to use Canadian. ___ computer-go

Re: [computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll results

2008-01-28 Thread Nick Wedd
In message [EMAIL PROTECTED], Nick Wedd [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes I have not yet updated the page http://www.weddslist.com/kgs/future.html, I shall do so today. I have updated that page. I have also spotted a problem - now the board sizes go in a 2-cycle, and the timezones also go in a

[computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll

2008-01-18 Thread Nick Wedd
It is two years and six months since I chose the format that we use for the monthly bot tournaments on KGS. Since then, things have changed: UCT has been invented, processing power has increased, pondering has been implemented in more programs, and CGOS is running. I get occasional requests

Re: [computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll

2008-01-18 Thread RĂ©mi Coulom
Hi, My vote would be to keep everything like it is. Maybe use round robin when the number of participants is close to the number of planned rounds. Also, don't hesitate to make the time control shorter if it would be necessary to fit enough rounds within a reasonable time, so we can play

Re: [computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll

2008-01-18 Thread David Doshay
Hello All, First, Thanks to Nick for doing these tournaments and for asking what we would like. Sticking with most of the replies I have seen so far, I will send my votes on the form directly to Nick, but will comment here on a few points. First, I am wondering about the 2-out-of-3

Re: [computer-go] KGS bot tournaments: poll

2008-01-18 Thread Christoph Birk
On Jan 18, 2008, at 9:41 AM, Nick Wedd wrote: The Formal/Open restriction was created to encourage commercial programs to compete. These programs' authors were wary of entering them in events in which they might have to play a whole bunch of GNU Go versions, so the Formal division was set