Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-04 Thread John Duncan Yoyo
That is the reason to ONLY run windows software in Parallels. You make a clean install once set it up the way you want. Save that file as master. Copy the file master file. Now run the copy until it gets wonky and toss it. Copy the master file again and start over. No prolonged reinstall.

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-04 Thread Tom Piwowar
That is the reason to ONLY run windows software in Parallels. You make a clean install once set it up the way you want. Save that file as master. Copy the file master file. Now run the copy until it gets wonky and toss it. Copy the master file again and start over. No prolonged reinstall.

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-03 Thread Tom Piwowar
FYI, the IEEE requires me to assign anything that I publish in their journals (for me, a lot) to them or I don't get published in their journals. And it makes sense that IEEE does. IEEE's goal is to distribute what you write via a variety of means (using known and as yet unknown technologies)

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-03 Thread mike
Didn't happen for macworld. No self destruct or MS-SS showing up in black boots and batons. And they alerted the entire world via internet and print they had violated the EULA. At worst, I think the software will install fine, run great and get infected via web pages like many windows

[CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-02 Thread Harvey Simon
On reflection, the proper way to think of the EULA might be this: You, the consumer, have purchased this software and we, the provider, will support you in your use of it, provided you agree to the following terms. If you don't agree, we're not a party to it, we're not liable for anything that

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread Stewart A. Marshall
Now I am not completely familiar with contracts such as these, but I am pretty sure the narrowly written contracts were the result of legal advice companies got when they had to battle former employees who took or attempted to patent items that were developed for companies on company time and

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread Constance Warner
If we all avoided software from convicted predatory monopolists it would only take a few years for things to get better. With competition and alternatives you would probably not be facing an EULA that you find so objectionable. Yes you have a problem. You should work to solve that problem.

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread mike
How is this even possible? Talking about installing a program on a computer has gone to talking about german resistance in WWII? In a few years are we going to read the diary of a young girl who lived with her family in the hidden basement of someone's home running vista home inside WINE in

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread Jordman
Thank you all for a really interesting conversation here. But I can't help mentioning that, with the lawyers in the justice department and the judges in our courts packed with radical right wing corporate ideologues, are the laws and the courts based on morality or rational thought any more?

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread mike
Except for all the radical left wing nutjob judges that pack our courts. Not much rational thought either way. Mike On 6/1/07, Jordman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thank you all for a really interesting conversation here. But I can't help mentioning that, with the lawyers in the justice

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread Stewart A. Marshall
I will go one step farther. The left is but a mirror image of the right! Stewart At 12:15 PM 6/1/2007, you wrote: Except for all the radical left wing nutjob judges that pack our courts. Not much rational thought either way. Mike On 6/1/07, Jordman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Thank you all

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-06-01 Thread Tom Piwowar
If we want to do something about unfair practices in the computer industry, we have to do something about the monopolistic corporations. It matters how you vote, and what kind of leadership we have in Washington. Yes. People who don't vote because it doesn't matter. People who vote for

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-31 Thread Tom Piwowar
Tom, I couldn't let this pass without comment: Please demonstrate. Buy some software, retail package or download, your choice. Start the installation. Decline the EULA. Return the product and try to get your money back. Let us know how that goes. This is a hot topic in the Linux community. Here

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-31 Thread Paul Meyer
!?!? You're kidding, right? Morality, ethics can be based on not wanting to hurt others, or it can be based on the notion that non-complicance by even a significant few can poison the well, so we should comply. AFAI can tell, contract and civil law is neither but based on the idea that

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-31 Thread Robert
I am reluctant to enter into this discussion, since I am conflicted about the issues. Were I 40 years younger, I would completely agree with Tom Piwowar that we all need to be honest as well as obeying the law -- all the stuff taught in Civics course in High School (never mind that my high

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-30 Thread John DeCarlo
On 5/30/07, Tom Piwowar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Me, I would say that the store is being immoral. And the EULA wouldn't hold up in most courts of law. And I would say the moral stand is to serve whatever food you buy from them to whomever you want. So you are going to take the good old two

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-30 Thread P Yasuda
Tom, I couldn't let this pass without comment: On 5/30/07, Tom Piwowar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: As Bill Gates once said If we tell them they have to put a ham sandwich in every box, they have to put a ham sandwich in every box. Your obligation is to read the EULA and according to the terms of

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-30 Thread John DeCarlo
On 5/30/07, P Yasuda [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: When our civilization falls, it won't be because Harvey violated Microsoft's EULA. Heck, I would argue that if everyone complied with Microsoft EULAs, then our civilization would have already fallen. (It is one of the sure signs of the

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-29 Thread Constance Warner
There are plenty of examples of contracts that we not able to negotiate, that are still enforceable. Negotiation is not a legal part of contract law. Did you enter into it with full knowledge is. Stewart Full knowledge of the EULA? Well, that's part of the point, isn't it? Does ANYBODY know

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-29 Thread Paul Meyer
Breaking a contract is a violation of civil law (perhaps) not criminal. The distinction is huge and is practical. As a fairly idealistic and even ideological person, this angst seems misplaced. Tom Piwowar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So, my question is: What, precisely, are all the things

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread John Duncan Yoyo
Given that EULA's aren't all that enforceable I'd say go ahead and try to install it in parallels. If it works fine. If it doesn't work the reason nobody wants to support it because you haven't paid enough money. MS will always take your money for an upgrade later if you really need support.

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread mike
It'll work, there is nothing written into the code that keeps you from doing it. Mike On 5/28/07, John Duncan Yoyo [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Given that EULA's aren't all that enforceable I'd say go ahead and try to install it in parallels. If it works fine. If it doesn't work the reason

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
EULA's get into contract law not criminal law. What is a contract worth if you are not going to keep it. Or to echo Tom's word, is it just a business decision. Would you want to shop at a grocery store where they view contracts as something only to be kept if it is to their advantage?

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread John DeCarlo
On 5/28/07, Rev. Stewart Marshall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: EULA's get into contract law not criminal law. What is a contract worth if you are not going to keep it. Or to echo Tom's word, is it just a business decision. Except the legal issue resolves around whether a EULA is a valid

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
OK I am not a lawyer nor do I play one on TV nor did I stay in a Holiday Inn Express last night. The moment you click an EULA, it is a legally binding contract between you and the producer of the product. Wether you like it or not does not matter. I do not like them anymore than you do, but

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread Rev. Stewart Marshall
Then take them to court I would be interested in the outcome. Stewart At 01:03 PM 5/28/2007, you wrote: On 5/28/07, Rev. Stewart Marshall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: The moment you click an EULA, it is a legally binding contract between you and the producer of the product. Wether you like it

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread b_s-wilk
Have there been cases where the software developer succeeded in suing for EULA violations? State? Federal? Foreign? * == QUICK LIST-COMMAND REFERENCE - Put the following commands in == * == the body of an email send 'em

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-28 Thread John DeCarlo
On 5/28/07, Rev. Stewart Marshall [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Then take them to court I would be interested in the outcome. Actually, some people do that. As usual with the US legal system, the court and lawyer costs are the biggest consideration. There are plenty of similar precedents over

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-25 Thread Snyder, Mark
One of the sins that comprised the gist of what was once said as: Sir! Have you no shame? Mark Snyder -Original Message- So, my question is: What, precisely, are all the things that could go wrong, were I to violate the EULA? Have we gotten to the point where every crime is just

Re: [CGUYS] The Consequences of EULA Violation

2007-05-25 Thread John DeCarlo
On 5/25/07, Tom Piwowar [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: So, my question is: What, precisely, are all the things that could go wrong, were I to violate the EULA? Have we gotten to the point where every crime is just another a business decision? If the benefit exceeds the fine or the probability of