Re: Graduation to TLP

Goal is the follow Apache's convention, so I think we will proceed with the same list, excluding those who have requested to be excluded. On Mon, Sep 18, 2017 at 11:00 AM Luciano Resende wrote: > On Mon, Aug 28, 2017 at 10:20 PM, Donald Szeto wrote: > >

Re: Graduation to TLP

On Mon, Aug 28, 2017 at 10:20 PM, Donald Szeto wrote: > Hi all, > > Since the ASF Board meeting in May ( > http://apache.org/foundation/records/minutes/2017/board_ > minutes_2017_05_17.txt), > PredictionIO has been considered nearing graduation and I think we are > almost

Re: Graduation to TLP

Donald / All, 1. Absolutely. +1 graduation. 2. I would be happy to stay onboard and participate. 3. I propose Donald as a VP, unless he is not willing to take it or we have another candidate in mind. Cheers, On Mon, Aug 28, 2017 at 10:20 PM, Donald Szeto wrote: > Hi all, >

Re: Graduation to TLP

It would be my pleasure to pick up TLP Chair responsibilities if nobody objects. Andrew, it would be really great and beneficial to the community if you could stay on mentoring as PMC of the new TLP. Could you also help update the project status page on the incubator site please? I will

Re: Graduation to TLP

Donald would be great. Donald - please think about it. It was suggested privately to me that I stay on from mentoring as PMC. If you'll have me, I would be glad to help the new TLP as/if needed. > On Sep 7, 2017, at 6:07 PM, Pat Ferrel wrote: > > This has been an

Re: Graduation to TLP

This has been an informal poll and it looks like people are ready. I suggest we push for graduation after the next release, which will be done by someone not Donald, I think we have 2 volunteers? I think this will be a requirement since it’s been mentioned by several IPMC members. I’d like to

Re: Graduation to TLP

I'd like to remain as committer and contribute my humble efforts to the prosperity of the project. > I propose we stay with the current PMC and committer list unless someone > wants to remove themselves. It may be good. In fact, most of committers carry out a task with limited time. Anyway I

Re: Graduation to TLP

+1 for graduation after 0.12.0. It has a binary distribution which makes PredictionIO easy to try. Also license of dependent libraries are now managed perfectly. I think it's a time to graduation. I want to stay PMC to continue to my work for PredictionIO after graduation as well. 2017-09-06

Re: Graduation to TLP

I personally don’t see much benefit in removing people unless they prove the exception. AFAIK this generally does not happen in ASF. I’m certainly not aware of the process except that it is easier in moving from podling to TLP. You prove some worthiness and once that’s done, it’s done. A poll

Re: Graduation to TLP

+1 for graduation On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Donald Szeto wrote: > Thanks for the clarification Pat! It always help to have Apache veterans to > provide historical context to these processes. > > As for me, I'd like to remain as PMC and committer. > > I like the idea of

Re: Graduation to TLP

Please continue to include me as a committer and PMC member. After some deliberation, I cannot take on further responsibility as VP at this time. *Mars On Tue, Sep 5, 2017 at 10:32 AM, Donald Szeto wrote: > Thanks for the clarification Pat! It always help to have Apache

Re: Graduation to TLP

Thanks for the clarification Pat! It always help to have Apache veterans to provide historical context to these processes. As for me, I'd like to remain as PMC and committer. I like the idea of polling the current committers and PMC, but like you said, most of them got pretty busy and may not be

Re: Graduation to TLP

+1 for graduation. I'm interested in roles for PMC and Release Management. shinsuke 2017-08-29 14:20 GMT+09:00 Donald Szeto : > Hi all, > > Since the ASF Board meeting in May ( > http://apache.org/foundation/records/minutes/2017/board_minutes_2017_05_17.txt), > PredictionIO

Re: Graduation to TLP

Some TLPs decide to rotate the Chair role on a yearly basis. Some keep them for as long as the Chair is willing. You should think about what kind of convention for Chair role ownership you'd like to see (if even you have a preference at this point). I have been Chair of two projects at one

Re: Graduation to TLP

IMO the VP/Chair responsibilities are mostly administrative and tedious. In the best case there is leadership but that will naturally come from thought leaders with no regard to title. On Aug 30, 2017, at 4:41 PM, Chan Lee wrote: Agree with everyone else. +1 for

Re: Graduation to TLP

Agree with everyone else. +1 for graduation. I was away for a while due to family issues, but I'd be happy to volunteer for release management. On Wed, Aug 30, 2017 at 4:30 PM, Pat Ferrel wrote: > Along with the link Donald gave, check this out: >

Re: Graduation to TLP

Along with the link Donald gave, check this out: http://community.apache.org/apache-way/apache-project-maturity-model.html We will need at least 2 release managers before graduation, any volunteers? On Aug 30, 2017,

Re: Graduation to TLP

Thank you Donald for leading the charge here, >From my perspective PredictionIO is already Apache in process & title. Graduation seems quite natural to reach top-level recognition. I'm interested in helping with PMC duties. Would be great to understand what the VP vs Member responsibilities look

Re: Graduation to TLP

I have had several people tell me they want to wait until PIO is not incubating before using it. This even after explaining that “incubating” has more to do with getting into the Apache Way of doing things and has no direct link to quality or community. I can only conclude from this that

Graduation to TLP

Hi all, Since the ASF Board meeting in May ( http://apache.org/foundation/records/minutes/2017/board_minutes_2017_05_17.txt), PredictionIO has been considered nearing graduation and I think we are almost there. I am kickstarting this thread so that we can discuss on these 3 things: 1. Does the