Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach James Bennett [2009.05.25.2047 +0200]: > And, really, this is the sort of thing that leads me to say it > shouldn't be in contrib right now. We do need to have some sort of > document outlining criteria, but I'd like to think that commitment to > a stable API

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

On Mon, May 25, 2009 at 12:43 PM, martin f krafft wrote: > Look what I found! Check out the fifth point, labeled #1, top-most > annoyance with Python, in And? While I like it as much as the next guy, django-tagging, to take your example, is currently sitting at version

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Dougal Matthews [2009.05.23.1823 +0200]: > Fair enough. I don't really have an issue with the idea, could be > quite handy. > > I can just imagine them saying no :) so thought I would question > it as a move/idea. Look what I found! Check out the fifth point,

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

Fair enough. I don't really have an issue with the idea, could be quite handy. I can just imagine them saying no :) so thought I would question it as a move/idea. Also, might be a good idea to wait until 1.1 is out the door so they have time to consider it properly... Dougal On 23/05/2009,

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Dougal Matthews [2009.05.23.1103 +0200]: > I don't think tagging is a particularly hard or non-trivial. No. All the more reason to push for a standard and prevent dozens of different implementations, no? > Anyway, this conversation is a bit irrelevant because;

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

I've never actually used it in any work related projects. I've only used it in personal messing around type projects... > Good contrib packages tackle issues that that are not trivial, are bikeshed > prone, and are difficult to get right for the common case. I don't think tagging is a

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Kai Kuehne [2009.05.23.1048 +0200]: > > Pretty must everybody does seem to use django-tagging unless > > they have some special weird use-case. > > Huh? Can you remove that "everybody", please? I've never used > tagging and I'm confident - many others too. I

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

Hi, On Fri, May 22, 2009 at 11:52 PM, Dougal Matthews wrote: > Pretty must everybody does seem to use django-tagging unless they have some > special weird use-case. Huh? Can you remove that "everybody", please? I've never used tagging and I'm confident - many others too.

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Dougal Matthews [2009.05.23.0232 +0200]: > It doesn't. Why should it? Well, because django-tagging is, quote Jacob: - optional - de-facto standard - the implementation of a common pattern Tagging is a very common feature nowadays, isn't it? Having tag

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

On 23 May 2009, at 02:32 , Dougal Matthews wrote: > It doesn't. Why should it? > To be blessed at the "true standard" for tagging, the way third-party python modules are pulled into the stdlib? --~--~-~--~~~---~--~~ You received this message because you are

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

It doesn't. Why should it? --- Dougal Matthews - @d0ugal http://www.dougalmatthews.com/ 2009/5/22 martin f krafft > also sprach Dougal Matthews [2009.05.22.2352 +0200]: > > Pretty must everybody does seem to use django-tagging unless they have > some

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Dougal Matthews [2009.05.22.2352 +0200]: > Pretty must everybody does seem to use django-tagging unless they have some > special weird use-case. > > I've used it every time I've needed tagging and don't have a gripe with it > yet. So how would it find its way

Re: de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

Pretty must everybody does seem to use django-tagging unless they have some special weird use-case. I've used it every time I've needed tagging and don't have a gripe with it yet. Cheers, Dougal --- Dougal Matthews - @d0ugal http://www.dougalmatthews.com/ 2009/5/22 martin f krafft

de-facto tagging (was: When do snippets get into Django?)

also sprach Alex Gaynor [2009.05.22.1545 +0200]: > http://jacobian.org/writing/what-is-django-contrib/ here is > a description of what one of the core developers see as the role > of django contrib. It should be noted that 2 of the core devs > said at euro django con that