Brent Meeker writes:
> > The brain-with-wires-attached cannot interact with the environment, because
> > all its sense organs have been removed and the stimulation is just coming
> > from
> > a recording. Instead of the wires + recording we could say that there is a
> > special
> > group o
Le 02-août-06, à 10:20, C. W. a écrit :
Hi, Bruno,
Sorry for my na鴳e question.
Common people would think that UDA is just imagination since you use the
teleportation
example and teleportation of human beings is still a science fiction.
Nobody can show that the substitution level really exists a
I totally agree that consciousness requires "outside" interaction.
That's the way we are. We are living beings that exist in a world.
We, as we are, couldn't exist otherwise. Things happen. We interact.
We make other things happen. The question of consciousness is a
contradiction. The questio
Tom Caylor writes:
> I totally agree that consciousness requires "outside" interaction.
> That's the way we are. We are living beings that exist in a world.
> We, as we are, couldn't exist otherwise. Things happen. We interact.
> We make other things happen. The question of consciousness is
CW writes:
> Hi, Bruno,
>
> Sorry for my na鴳e question.
> Common people would think that UDA is just imagination since you use the
> teleportation
> example and teleportation of human beings is still a science fiction.
> Nobody can show that the substitution level really exists and teleportat
Russell Standish writes:
> In the Multiverse, there is a huge difference between a recording and
> the actual computation. Only in one single universe (or history) of
> the ensemble do the two coincide.
>
> The "recording is a computation" issue is only a problem for single
> universe theory IMH
>From: Bruno Marchal
>All we need to *reason* for getting consequence of comp is that such
>substitution is *in principle* possible. Theoreticians does that, in many >
>fields. I insist that the UDA (Universal Dovetailer Argument) is based on
>the notion of generalized brain: you could say that
CW writes:
> >From: Stathis Papaioannou
> >Do you believe that IF you vanished at point A and a copy of you created at
> >point B who was physically and mentally similar to the original to the same
> >extent as if you had walked from A to B you would have survived? If you
> >answer "no" then y
8 matches
Mail list logo
