Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-21 Thread John Howell
At 11:01 AM -0500 12/18/10, Christopher Smith wrote: Wouldn't iPads be substantially heavier than an average choral folder, and more likely to be dropped? All the choirs I see have at least one folder drop per rehearsal/concert. I haven't handled one, so I don't know. And of course if a folde

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-19 Thread David H. Bailey
The iPad definitely is a blast! :-) David H. Bailey On 12/19/2010 11:45 AM, Allen Fisher wrote: You know, I thought about that, but my book is pretty heavy for this group (we have 50+ winter/xmas/holiday songs that we do) so at least for my purposes it will be about the same I thought abou

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-19 Thread Allen Fisher
You know, I thought about that, but my book is pretty heavy for this group (we have 50+ winter/xmas/holiday songs that we do) so at least for my purposes it will be about the same I thought about the dropping issue too, and there are some options out there for protecting the pad if dropped tha

{Spam} Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-19 Thread David H. Bailey
On 12/18/2010 11:01 AM, Christopher Smith wrote: Wouldn't iPads be substantially heavier than an average choral folder, and more likely to be dropped? All the choirs I see have at least one folder drop per rehearsal/concert. Nothing is going to prevent clumsy people from being clumsy. I've

{Spam} Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-19 Thread David H. Bailey
On 12/18/2010 10:54 AM, Allen Fisher wrote: I am actually looking at setting this up for myself, as part of a small group that I sing with. Since it's choral scores, the iPad's about the right size to display a page. I was also considering making an app that could take PDF files with a more musi

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-18 Thread Christopher Smith
Wouldn't iPads be substantially heavier than an average choral folder, and more likely to be dropped? All the choirs I see have at least one folder drop per rehearsal/concert. Christopher On Sat Dec 18, at SaturdayDec 18 10:54 AM, Allen Fisher wrote: > I am actually looking at setting this up

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-18 Thread Allen Fisher
I am actually looking at setting this up for myself, as part of a small group that I sing with. Since it's choral scores, the iPad's about the right size to display a page. I was also considering making an app that could take PDF files with a more musician-friendly interface for turning pages (

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Christopher Smith
On 9-Dec-10, at 9-Dec-10 9:24 PM, John Howell wrote: At 7:57 PM -0500 12/9/10, Christopher Smith wrote: But what was your point about comparing my arranging rate with union (yes) musicians' salaries? I would use that as a point for comparison, yes. I earned $1500 for that gig, and the pa

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Chuck Israels
On Dec 9, 2010, at 6:24 PM, John Howell wrote: > > Has the union ever actually set rates for arranging? I've never been aware > of it, but of course any union scale would only be a MINIMUM figure, and no > good arrangers whose work is in demand would settle for that. What fantasy world are w

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 7:57 PM -0500 12/9/10, Christopher Smith wrote: But what was your point about comparing my arranging rate with union (yes) musicians' salaries? I would use that as a point for comparison, yes. I earned $1500 for that gig, and the part that paid $1000 took a heck of a lot more than twice as

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread David W. Fenton
On 9 Dec 2010 at 10:34, Eric Dannewitz wrote: > But seriously, tech support for an iPad? Yes, of course, if you're talking about an entire ensemble using them, as opposed to an individual musician. Just as an orchestra needs a music librarian, electronic music stands of whatever form (iPad or

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 2:30 PM -0800 12/9/10, Eric Dannewitz wrote: On Dec 9, 2010, at 1:54 PM, John Howell wrote: > Item: Time spent "stuffing" the iPads compared with time to stuff the orchestra folders. They'd have to be done one at a time if there is no networking, and if there IS networking the number o

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Christopher Smith
On Thu Dec 9, at ThursdayDec 9 7:07 PM, John Howell wrote: > At 4:18 PM -0500 12/9/10, Christopher Smith wrote: >> Yeah, I just had a little discussion with a client hiring the orchestra I >> play with. They wanted a local anthem arranged (7 minutes long, fer the love >> of Pete!) for full orch

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 1:35 PM -0800 12/9/10, Chuck Israels wrote: On Dec 9, 2010, at 12:59 PM, Eric Dannewitz wrote: Exactlyand since the sound system and the wireless mic system never really works it makes me wonder such as well.. In my experience, sound systems rarely work as advertised to solve prob

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 4:18 PM -0500 12/9/10, Christopher Smith wrote: Yeah, I just had a little discussion with a client hiring the orchestra I play with. They wanted a local anthem arranged (7 minutes long, fer the love of Pete!) for full orchestra and 4 singers, and wanted to pay $300 for it! I asked $1000 and

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Well, it is the community center.they have all kinds of money to throw around... My tax dollars being flushed away... On Dec 9, 2010, at 3:07 PM, John Howell wrote: > Ah, but he said "the communities," not the "community orchestras." Your tax > dollars at work! > > John

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 12:59 PM -0800 12/9/10, Eric Dannewitz wrote: Exactlyand since the sound system and the wireless mic system never really works it makes me wonder such as well.. They work just fine if they are well selected and well cared for, and run by competent technicians who know what they're d

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 2:35 PM -0600 12/9/10, Robert Patterson wrote: Lucky community orchestras!!! (But I have to say, as a musician I'd be wondering how they could afford a 150K sound system but couldn't afford to pay me!) Ah, but he said "the communities," not the "community orchestras." Your tax dollars at wo

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Yup, don't you love the economy and stuff.. On Dec 9, 2010, at 1:18 PM, Christopher Smith wrote: > Yeah, I just had a little discussion with a client hiring the orchestra I > play with. They wanted a local anthem arranged (7 minutes long, fer the love > of Pete!) for full orchestra and 4 s

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Well, I'm already seeing small groups use the iPad.perhaps not for a big group. I didn't even consider the Stand Partner thing On Dec 9, 2010, at 2:06 PM, John Howell wrote: > Oh? For a community orchestra like ours, that has an annual budget barely > distinguishable from zero? No

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
On Dec 9, 2010, at 1:54 PM, John Howell wrote: >> > OK, maybe I've just produced too many concerts and shows, and had to learn to > read between the lines to anticipate the problems that MIGHT come up or WOULD > come up. > > Item: Time spent "stuffing" the iPads compared with time to stuff t

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Christopher Smith
Yeah, I just had a little discussion with a client hiring the orchestra I play with. They wanted a local anthem arranged (7 minutes long, fer the love of Pete!) for full orchestra and 4 singers, and wanted to pay $300 for it! I asked $1000 and told them that it would be twice that (at least) und

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
Oh? For a community orchestra like ours, that has an annual budget barely distinguishable from zero? Not likely. And just to mention it in passing, community orchestras also tend to have a number of older members whose eyesight is not that of a 20-year-old any more. Yes, I'm playing devil's

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 10:34 AM -0800 12/9/10, Eric Dannewitz wrote: But seriously, tech support for an iPad? I mean...really? If the orchestra's librarian is on top of it, they would have them charged and loaded with a playlist of all the songs for the concert. OK, maybe I've just produced too many c

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Chuck Israels
On Dec 9, 2010, at 12:59 PM, Eric Dannewitz wrote: > Exactlyand since the sound system and the wireless mic system never > really works it makes me wonder such as well.. In my experience, sound systems rarely work as advertised to solve problems (outdoor venues excepted). It has also

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Exactlyand since the sound system and the wireless mic system never really works it makes me wonder such as well.. On Dec 9, 2010, at 12:35 PM, Robert Patterson wrote: > Lucky community orchestras!!! (But I have to say, as a musician I'd be > wondering how they could afford a 150K sound

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Robert Patterson
Lucky community orchestras!!! (But I have to say, as a musician I'd be wondering how they could afford a 150K sound system but couldn't afford to pay me!) On Thu, Dec 9, 2010 at 12:57 PM, Eric Dannewitz wrote: > Hmm, the communities around where I live can blow money on things like a > Meyer soun

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Hmm, the communities around where I live can blow money on things like a Meyer sound system ($150K) for their little theater..so iPads would be a little bump for them.. On Dec 9, 2010, at 10:50 AM, Robert Patterson wrote: > Most community orchestras I know don't even own their own Manh

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Dean M. Estabrook
I was in attendance at a Sacramento Symphony concert years ago when, in the middle of Beethoven's 6th (Mvt. 2 I think), every light in the hall went out. The orchestra just kept playing until even those with excellent memories couldn't go on. It was one of the most magnificent decrescendo

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Robert Patterson
Most community orchestras I know don't even own their own Manhassetts, much less being able to aford to provide iPads to the members. On Thu, Dec 9, 2010 at 12:46 PM, Eric Dannewitz wrote: > Perhaps not for an entrenched organization like Philly Orchestra, but for > community Orchestras maybe. To

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Perhaps not for an entrenched organization like Philly Orchestra, but for community Orchestras maybe. Totally for smaller groups. On Dec 9, 2010, at 10:44 AM, Robert Patterson wrote: > Are you seriously proposing an iPad for, e.g., the Philadelphia Orchestra? > Have you ever read the MOLA guide

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Robert Patterson
Are you seriously proposing an iPad for, e.g., the Philadelphia Orchestra? Have you ever read the MOLA guidelines for part sizes? On Thu, Dec 9, 2010 at 12:34 PM, Eric Dannewitz wrote: > See, if you had iPad's you could have saved the show. > > But seriously, tech support for an iPad? I mean.

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Robert Patterson
In my experience, network issues are far more likely than power outages, and they tend to take longer and require higher-paid technicians to resolve. But by the time music-stand technology is affordable for an orchestra, it is quite possible that network technology will be as robust as power. My po

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
See, if you had iPad's you could have saved the show. But seriously, tech support for an iPad? I mean...really? If the orchestra's librarian is on top of it, they would have them charged and loaded with a playlist of all the songs for the concert. Maybe the addition of a foot pedal

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 10:01 AM -0600 12/9/10, Robert Patterson wrote: Another consideration for a group like an orchestra is, with everything else that can go wrong, do you really want to add network tech. support to your list of headaches when every minute of network outage during a rehearsal could cost you hundre

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
Seriously? Tech support? For an iPad? What, is it going to get a virus? People aren't going to figure out how to touch it and get it to work right? I mean,other than keeping it charged..there isn't a whole lot that requires "tech" support Sent from my iSomething On Dec 9, 2010, at 8:01 AM, R

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Eric Dannewitz
There are quite a few people, including myself, who would disagree. Have you even tried using an iPad or are you proclaiming all this from you comfy armchair? Seriously, the iPad works great as a electric music stand, and if you have a page turning foot pedal (I don't yet but soon) it is even bett

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread Robert Patterson
Another consideration for a group like an orchestra is, with everything else that can go wrong, do you really want to add network tech. support to your list of headaches when every minute of network outage during a rehearsal could cost you hundreds of dollars? On Wed, Dec 8, 2010 at 10:46 AM, John

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-09 Thread John Howell
At 7:15 AM -0800 12/8/10, Chuck Israels wrote: Dear David, I have seen no discussion of this, but one is certainly due. iPad size is an issue for me. I don't like a music stand right in my face, and the iPad does need to be closer than the 9.5 x 12.5 parts I print. I have seen a player her

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-08 Thread Eric Dannewitz
It works perfect as a music display. Ive been scanning books and converting all kinds of stuff into PDF format for it. Now I just need to get the page turning foot pedal thing and I'll be set. Sent from my iSomething On Dec 8, 2010, at 6:31 AM, "David H. Bailey" wrote: > I can't recall if

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-08 Thread Chuck Israels
Dear David, I have seen no discussion of this, but one is certainly due. iPad size is an issue for me. I don't like a music stand right in my face, and the iPad does need to be closer than the 9.5 x 12.5 parts I print. I have seen a player here in Portland use one for reading lead sheets and

Re: [Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-08 Thread Robert Patterson
I tried the with a simple PDF reader called CloudReader for a conduction seminar. Obviously this gave me no way to add eyeglasses or what have you. I would rate the experience as B-, and if I do it again I'll go ahead and print out the materials. A big issue is how fast the pages turn. I chose Clo

[Finale] {Spam} iPad as electronic music stand

2010-12-08 Thread David H. Bailey
I can't recall if this has been discussed on tpin or not (but then again I can't even remember what I had for dinner last night) so I thought I would ask if anybody is using an iPad as an electronic music stand. I've looked into the dedicated Freehand MusicPadPro but am also considering the iP