Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-23 Thread Brian May
On 19 December 2014 at 11:01, Andrew Roffey and...@roffey.org wrote: Replicant along with the F-Droid app store is a far better example of a mobile operating system which attempts to provide software freedom for users, although its actual use is quite limited, even more so than GNU/Linux on

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-23 Thread Russell Coker
Surely the source of the f-droid app is also available so that project can be forked if they aren't getting new versions fast enough. On December 23, 2014 9:19:11 PM GMT+11:00, Brian May br...@microcomaustralia.com.au wrote: On 19 December 2014 at 11:01, Andrew Roffey and...@roffey.org wrote:

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-23 Thread Adam Bolte
On 23/12/14 21:59, Russell Coker wrote: Surely the source of the f-droid app is also available so that project can be forked if they aren't getting new versions fast enough. You don't even need to go that far. Just host your own repo with newer versions of the packages. F-Droid encourages

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-21 Thread Martin Ebourne
On Fri, 2014-12-19 at 23:56 +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: You might have to clarify this, I did a quick look at JB Hifi and could only find a refurbished 10inch samsung tablet for $398 (

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-21 Thread Russell Coker
On Fri, 19 Dec 2014, Adam Bolte abo...@systemsaviour.com wrote: You both seem to be talking about two different things. Ben was saying that you can run whatever app store you want - you are not forced to use Google. This is absolutely true. On my Sony Xperia Z1 Ultra phablet running Android, I

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-21 Thread Adam Bolte
On Mon, Dec 22, 2014 at 04:19:07PM +1100, Russell Coker wrote: But I think that a large portion of the inconvenience of running non-Google apps is due to the lack of testing. That sounds reasonable. Nexus devices are the most well known for having an unlocked boot loader. Lots of other

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-19 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 19 December 2014 at 12:56, Adam Bolte abo...@systemsaviour.com wrote: Perhaps we have different ideas about what is meant by vendor lock-in. From Wikipedia: Adam, I agree on all these points, I just don't think they make a big difference in an educational environment. You give someone $200

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
Android apps that you purchase will work on products from Google (Nexus), Samsung, HTC, LG, and other companies. iOS apps that you purchase will only work on products from Apple. I think this only tells part of the story - You are still being locked in to google ecosystem, (to access

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Ben Finney
Noah O'Donoghue noah.odonog...@gmail.com writes: You are [by deploying Android tablets in a public school] still being locked in to google ecosystem, (to access Google Play) The advantage of Android, as contrasted with iOS, is that it's quite straightforward to never use Google Play, and there

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 19 December 2014 at 10:24, Ben Finney ben+freesoftw...@benfinney.id.au wrote: The advantage of Android, as contrasted with iOS, is that it's quite straightforward to never use Google Play, and there are plenty of apps available from non-Google app stores. Ben, it sure doesn't seem that

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 19 December 2014 at 10:44, Andrew Pam xa...@sericyb.com.au wrote: Or install Cyanogenmod. Cheers, Andrew I had to do that for a friend on his HTC.. It involved downgrading the firmware to one that was vulnerable to a boot rom exploit, exploiting the boot rom, patching recovery,

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
The advantage of Android, as contrasted with iOS, is that it's quite straightforward to never use Google Play, and there are plenty of apps available from non-Google app stores. On 19 December 2014 at 10:51, Ben Finney ben+freesoftw...@benfinney.id.au wrote: What in particular are you

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Tony Morris
Has it been established, with regard to the goals, that it is reasonable to talk about iOS versus Android? For example, my children use archlinux at a school that requires mandatory Apple or Windows [because we give you the choice!] They are able to do this after I engaged in some negotiation

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Andrew Roffey
Android apps that you purchase will work on products from Google (Nexus), Samsung, HTC, LG, and other companies. iOS apps that you purchase will only work on products from Apple. I think this only tells part of the story - You are still being locked in to google ecosystem, (to access

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 19 December 2014 at 10:59, Tony Morris tmor...@tmorris.net wrote: Has it been established, with regard to the goals, that it is reasonable to talk about iOS versus Android? For example, my children use archlinux at a school that requires mandatory Apple or Windows [because we give you the

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Fraser Tweedale
On Fri, Dec 19, 2014 at 11:08:51AM +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: On 19 December 2014 at 10:59, Tony Morris tmor...@tmorris.net wrote: Has it been established, with regard to the goals, that it is reasonable to talk about iOS versus Android? For example, my children use archlinux at a

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Adam Bolte
On Fri, Dec 19, 2014 at 10:35:01AM +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: On 19 December 2014 at 10:24, Ben Finney ben+freesoftw...@benfinney.id.au wrote: The advantage of Android, as contrasted with iOS, is that it's quite straightforward to never use Google Play, and there are plenty of apps

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 19 December 2014 at 11:26, Adam Bolte abo...@systemsaviour.com wrote: You both seem to be talking about two different things. Ben was saying that you can run whatever app store you want - you are not forced to use Google. This is absolutely true. On my Sony Xperia Z1 Ultra phablet running

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Adam Bolte
On Fri, Dec 19, 2014 at 11:53:55AM +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: I think the main part of my argument was that there is vendor lock in on any platform. Google has less, but it's more of a technicality in the frame of the larger argument which was tablets in school environments. Because it's a

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-18 Thread Martin Ebourne
On Thu, 2014-12-18 at 12:13 +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: I've been on conferences where teachers talk for days about all the apps they are using in their classroom and the ways they are using them for educational outcomes. There are just so many apps available. Here's a link to multiple pages

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Fraser Tweedale
On Thu, Dec 18, 2014 at 12:13:39PM +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: As someone actually responsible for deploying iPads in primary schools I feel like I should comment. I'm going to present a couple of arguments for iPads, without disagreeing with the closed ecosystem being bad. I believe an

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
I hear the walled garden argument a lot and it's definitely true in a financial sense with apps - people won't move away from iOS because they have spent $X on iTunes apps. As far as in a school environment there is an important distinction around who purchased the apps - If it was the school,

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Fraser Tweedale
On Thu, Dec 18, 2014 at 01:37:18PM +1100, Noah O'Donoghue wrote: I hear the walled garden argument a lot and it's definitely true in a financial sense with apps - people won't move away from iOS because they have spent $X on iTunes apps. As far as in a school environment there is an

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Tony Morris
On 18/12/14 12:56, Fraser Tweedale wrote: I'm was thinking more along lines of being about to bypass app stores or official software channels and run on your device whatever software you wish. My understanding is that it's difficult on iOS. It is indeed unnecessarily difficult to work toward

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Noah O'Donoghue
On 18 December 2014 at 13:56, Fraser Tweedale fr...@frase.id.au wrote: I'm was thinking more along lines of being about to bypass app stores or official software channels and run on your device whatever software you wish. My understanding is that it's difficult on iOS. Yeah, they run a PKI

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Russell Coker
On Thu, 18 Dec 2014, Noah O'Donoghue noah.odonog...@gmail.com wrote: Actually Android wins handily when you start looking at such things. If you want a device that's smaller, larger, lighter, cheaper, or has a longer battery life then there's an Android device that wins. Apple makes a

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-12-17 Thread Russell Coker
On Thu, 18 Dec 2014, Noah O'Donoghue noah.odonog...@gmail.com wrote: However, I'm not really convinced that the alternatives are any less lock-in, because the android apps you purchase only work on android devices.. So what's the difference? If you move away to another platform Android apps

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-11-25 Thread Russell Coker
On Tue, 25 Nov 2014, Fraser Tweedale fr...@frase.id.au wrote: My sons' school is next on the bandwagon it seems, more information here: http://www.craigburn.sa.edu.au/files/BYOD%20iPads/innovative_learning_prg ram_craigburn.pdf The Managing and operating ICT line seems to go against

[free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-11-24 Thread Martin Ebourne
Hi all, I've been lurking on this list for quite a while now, because it is a topic that interests me. I would come to some of the meetings, but I am in Adelaide so that somewhat precludes it. :-( Anyhow I have an issue that concerns me and I'd be interested in other people's experiences in this

Re: [free-software-melb] Mandatory ipads in schools

2014-11-24 Thread Fraser Tweedale
On Tue, Nov 25, 2014 at 03:41:36PM +1030, Martin Ebourne wrote: Hi all, I've been lurking on this list for quite a while now, because it is a topic that interests me. I would come to some of the meetings, but I am in Adelaide so that somewhat precludes it. :-( Anyhow I have an issue that