Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-06 Thread Björn Grüning
Hi, the first one is the one we are currently working on. It's an interface to create your own Galaxy Docker flavours. Drag Drop your tools data managers and so on ... click build and either get a Docker Image or a Docker file. But everything is in flux at the moment. So please jump in and

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-05 Thread Björn Grüning
Hi Brian, Oksana, let's move this discussion to github and try to get something done for the next+1 release. 15.07/15.08 or what ever it will be is really close so I would like to not rush here. But as soon as we have release this version. We can try to get something in :dev that addresses these

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-05 Thread Björn Grüning
Thanks! @Brian please add your ideas and use cases so we can figure out a way how to support this :) Thanks, Bjoern Am 05.08.2015 um 16:26 schrieb Oksana Korol: Created issue #74, with reference to this discussion. Cheers, Oksana On Wed, Aug 5, 2015 at 9:52 AM, Björn Grüning

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-05 Thread Tiago Rodrigues Antao
On Tue, 4 Aug 2015 17:26:00 + Kandalaft, Iyad iyad.kandal...@agr.gc.ca wrote: As a supplement to Oksana's original inquiry, we, at AAFC, couple Galaxy to SGE and possibly a different grid engine in the future for job scheduling. The old-fashioned way of doing that is to unify storage

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-05 Thread Eric Rasche
Tiago, Some work is already in progress for that. Please see - http://wookoouk.github.io/galaxyFlavorGenerator/ - https://github.com/galaxyFlavorsGenerators/galaxyFlavorGenerator/ I don't believe it handles configuration of the cluster backend, but I'm sure that would be a good addition

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-04 Thread Björn Grüning
Am 04.08.2015 um 00:00 schrieb Tiago Rodrigues Antao: On Mon, 03 Aug 2015 17:30:05 +0200 Björn Grüning bjoern.gruen...@gmail.com wrote: I would recommend you Galaxy Flavours. We have a few, for example RNA-Seq, ChIP-seq etc ... join us! :) That was my first port of call, but they lacked

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-04 Thread Brian Claywell
On Sun, Aug 2, 2015 at 4:59 AM, Oksana oko...@gmail.com wrote: We only have one cluster, so we will have both test and production environments running on it. I understand that at a minimum we'd need different Galaxy home dir and UID/GID. For our local deployment of Galaxy with Docker, which

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-03 Thread Tiago Rodrigues Antao
On Mon, 03 Aug 2015 17:30:05 +0200 Björn Grüning bjoern.gruen...@gmail.com wrote: I would recommend you Galaxy Flavours. We have a few, for example RNA-Seq, ChIP-seq etc ... join us! :) That was my first port of call, but they lacked quite a few tools. For example the RNA-Seq lacked tophat,

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-03 Thread Tiago Rodrigues Antao
Hi, I am also thinking in doing something similar. My idea would be to deploy a galaxy docker on demand per project. The docker would have a galaxy installation that would be configured to join a cluster. Most of the computation would actually occur on the cluster. Each project would thus have

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-02 Thread Björn Grüning
Hi, I will think about this, but this comes with the price of doing much of the internal stuff during startup, which also have it's downsides. Can you tell me what your admin wants to do, maybe we find a solution without changing the build-time variables? For example we can talk to schedulers

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-02 Thread Oksana
We only have one cluster, so we will have both test and production environments running on it. I understand that at a minimum we'd need different Galaxy home dir and UID/GID. This is a proof of concept for us still, so I can't tell you what else we might need to change. I can get hold of our

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-01 Thread Björn Grüning
Hi Oksana, both variables are used during container build to create users and home directories. This does not happen during container startup. They are buildtime variables. All Galaxy ENV vars are runtime variables and do have an impact during startup. Can you tell us more about what you want

Re: [galaxy-dev] Externalizing Galaxy config in docker-galaxy-stable

2015-08-01 Thread Oksana
Hi Bjorn, Our team is trying to streamline our Galaxy development process, by using your docker container for development, test and production environments. To do that, our sys admin needs to be able to change a few of Galaxy build time variables, like the ones that I've mentioned and probably