Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-08-08 Thread Roger W Suhr
With the new flash drives there are no more SPINNING parts. Sent from my Verizon, Samsung Galaxy smartphone Get Outlook for Android From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List on behalf of Phil Smith III Sent: Tuesday, August 8, 2023 2:18:14 PM

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-08-08 Thread Phil Smith III
Colin Paice wrote: >These days disks are virtualized. I think the unit is the track. Two >"adjacent" tracks from a data set perspective could be on different PC >sized disks in the disk subsystem. The "disks" are usually irrelevant >as the data is usually in cache! This gets humorous at

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-20 Thread Leonard D Woren
Jon Perryman wrote on 7/19/2023 8:00 PM: Sysplex is the ability to tightly couple up to 32 z16 boxes. I know what Sysplex is, and it is decades older than z16. Sysplex is a software construct, not hardware, although certain hardware is required to implement it. Sysplex is both software

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-20 Thread Tom Marchant
You have just convinced me that your posts are not worth reading. On Thu, 20 Jul 2023 03:00:38 +, Jon Perryman wrote: > >>How could you not find official references when so many people are > >>infuriated. > >> How dare I fail to read everything that you do! > >> If this was a Linux list

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-20 Thread Ed Jaffe
On 7/20/2023 6:20 AM, John Abell wrote: Like the prediction in 1970 or so that COBOL would be obsolete I worked for a major SoCal bank from 1982-1986. The programmers there used to say COBOL stood for "Completely Obsolete Business-Oriented Language!" Man, were they wrong! -- Phoenix

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-20 Thread John Abell
] On Behalf Of Roger W Suhr Sent: Thursday, July 20, 2023 9:16 AM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years? Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years? That's what they said in 1995! Please let me know if you have any questions, or concerns! Thank You! Roger W Suhr

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-20 Thread Roger W Suhr
Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years? That's what they said in 1995! Please let me know if you have any questions, or concerns! Thank You! Roger W Suhr suhr...@gmail.com 563-581-9065 (from my personal laptop) -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Jon

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Brennan
I just ran a test config for a full z16 A01 and it had the limits I mentioned. I am impressed! For the past few years upgrades have generally gone from 2 cables to 4 cables which can be a surprise for the facilities folks. I can't even comprehend 8 x 32 = 256 14 foot cables. A couple of

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Perryman
> That 1,536 doesn't sound right.  Max I/O drawers on a z16 A01 is 12 (see > page 20 in the pdf you linked).  So 12 x 16 = 192 cards.  And if all of > them are 2 port cards, max ports is 384.  And that still leaves CEC > slots for 36 dual port ICA cards to connect that huge mass. On page 22,

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Perryman
>>How could you not find official references when so many people are >>infuriated. > How dare I fail to read everything that you do! > If this was a Linux list perhaps your arrogant response would be warranted. I don't look at much Linux stuff these days but IBM RHEL closed source is

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Brennan
> An IBM z16 Max200 fully loaded has 256 cores where 200 cores > are available to the customer, 40TB ram and 1,536 (4 CPC draws > with 12 fanout adapters each containing 2 ports connecting to > a 16 PCIe slot I/O drawer)? That 1,536 doesn't sound right. Max I/O drawers on a z16 A01 is 12 (see

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Perryman
> What a BS 'survey' What is it you consider to be BS? Are you saying that the hardware numbers are wrong?  An IBM z16 Max200 fully loaded has 256 cores where 200 cores are available to the customer, 40TB ram and 1,536 (4 CPC draws with 12 fanout adapters each containing 2 ports connecting

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Marchant
On Wed, 19 Jul 2023 18:54:04 +, Jon Perryman wrote: > >> You didn't bother to cite any reference, so I am highly skeptical.  >> I looked for this "announcement" and didn't find it. > > >How could you not find official references when so many people are infuriated. How dare I fail to read

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Perryman
> Container orchestration exists because some of those containers (or the > hosts they may run on) may have a problem. Containers is just one of multiple solutions to a problem that most people don't grasp.  Ask yourself what problems does Kubernetes containers resolve. The problem exists on

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Perryman
> You didn't bother to cite any reference, so I am highly skeptical.  > I looked for this "announcement" and didn't find it. How could you not find official references when so many people are infuriated. For instance, see 

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Schmitt, Michael
Considering that VSE still exists, the answer would be no. How long ago was it that IBM tried to cancel VSE, but relented due to customer demand? -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Jon Perryman Sent: Tuesday, July 18, 2023 7:47 PM To:

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Marchant
On Wed, 19 Jul 2023 15:41:44 +, Kevin Mckenzie wrote: > 2. RedHat is not moving to closed source. RedHat couldn't make RHEL closed > source if they wanted to. RedHat doesn't own the copyright to something like > 90% of RHEL, and whatever copyright they do own, they've assigned to the

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Matt Hogstrom
Kevin’s note is a great summary. FWIW, years ago when I worked for IBM (early 2000’s) we met with RedHat. During the introductions someone from IBM referred to them as an Open Source company. One of the RedHat execs corrected them and said, “We are a commercial software company that uses

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Marchant
On Wed, 19 Jul 2023 00:47:04 +, Jon Perryman wrote: >IBM RHEL announced it's move to closed source (IBM RedHat Enterprise Linux). You didn't bother to cite any reference, so I am highly skeptical. I looked for this "announcement" and didn't find it. Linux is licensed under the GPL. It

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Tom Brennan
Thanks! That helps me understand things much better. I looked through the survey and the questions were way over my head. On 7/19/2023 8:41 AM, Kevin Mckenzie wrote: Let me try to respond to some of this; keeping in mind that I know nothing of the business decisions here, and am speaking

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Kevin Mckenzie
Let me try to respond to some of this; keeping in mind that I know nothing of the business decisions here, and am speaking for myself, not IBM. 1. As far as I’m aware, IBM is still very separate from RedHat. Maybe things are different at the board level, but at my level, there is an

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Mike Schwab
z\OS containers being crucial? Absolutely. Some z\OS, DB/2, etc. upgrades require applications, subsystems, LPARs, Sysplexes, etc. At a certain stage before proceeding to the next stage. Hopefully these requirements can be limited to one or a small subset of containers. On Wed, Jul 19, 2023,

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jon Butler
Has anyone considered that z/OS is knee-capped so it only runs on GPs? Are we suggesting that people will buy GPs at 10 times the price rather than IFLs or zIIPs just so they can run z/OS under Linux? -- For IBM-MAIN subscribe

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Michael Watkins
What a BS 'survey'. -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Jon Perryman Sent: Tuesday, July 18, 2023 7:47 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years? CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the Texas Comptroller's email

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Bill Johnson
I feel like I’m arguing with the same people who thought the mainframe was going to be obsolete by Y2K. Very poor fit NOW. In 10 years, perhaps not. Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone On Wednesday, July 19, 2023, 9:28 AM, Jay Maynard wrote: Yes, it is, because quantum computing enables solving

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Jay Maynard
Yes, it is, because quantum computing enables solving classes of problems that current machines can't. But it is a very poor fit for the overwhelming majority of computing tasks today. Put another way: a z/Series vector facility isn't going to do much good computing payroll. Neither is a quantum

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread Bill Johnson
Billions is being spent on developing quantum computing. I doubt it’s because they’ve got money to waste. https://newsroom.ibm.com/2023-05-21-IBM-Launches-100-Million-Partnership-with-Global-Universities-to-Develop-Novel-Technologies-Towards-a-100,000-Qubit-Quantum-Centric-Supercomputer

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-19 Thread kekronbekron
> There are a lot of very wise an experienced folks who have quite clearly > stated that conatainers are critical to the future of z/OS. And I don't doubt them, and surely my knowledge is far more limited. What portion of it (containers being critical to zOS's future) is because zOS has to play

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread David Crayford
> On 19 Jul 2023, at 12:44 pm, kekronbekron > <02dee3fcae33-dmarc-requ...@listserv.ua.edu> wrote: > > The "gift" is not containers but container tech... layering. > Just lifting and shifting distributed tech onto mainframe, with no > consideration of the extreme complexities is very

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread kekronbekron
The "gift" is not containers but container tech... layering. Just lifting and shifting distributed tech onto mainframe, with no consideration of the extreme complexities is very wasteful. Container orchestration exists because some of those containers (or the hosts they may run on) may have a

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread David Crayford
> On 19 Jul 2023, at 9:52 am, kekronbekron > <02dee3fcae33-dmarc-requ...@listserv.ua.edu> wrote: > > Here's a dumb and bold prediction - the guts of RHEL (CoreOS) will be laid > bare within zOS. Nice idea, but I doubt it. > USS becomes LSS. zOS native containers are actually normal

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread David Crayford
> On 19 Jul 2023, at 11:28 am, zMan wrote: > > Bill, Bill, Bill. Stick to stuff you know something about. IF quantum > computers ever become realistically powerful, they will have VERY specific > uses. They are not suited for general-purpose computing. Nobody even > quantum-adjacent disputes

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread zMan
Bill, Bill, Bill. Stick to stuff you know something about. IF quantum computers ever become realistically powerful, they will have VERY specific uses. They are not suited for general-purpose computing. Nobody even quantum-adjacent disputes that, as even the most cursory reading of the research

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread kekronbekron
Here's a dumb and bold prediction - the guts of RHEL (CoreOS) will be laid bare within zOS. USS becomes LSS. zOS native containers are actually normal containers that you see in the linux world. DSFS and zCX end up helping to blur the boundaries between zOS and LSS. zOS is not going away. But we

Re: Will z/OS be obsolete in 5 years?

2023-07-18 Thread Bill Johnson
Quantum computing is the future. And IBM is the leader.  https://www.forbes.com/sites/karlfreund/2023/06/14/ibm-achieves-breakthrough-in-quantum-computing/ Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone On Tuesday, July 18, 2023, 8:47 PM, Jon Perryman wrote: IBM RHEL announced it's move to closed source