The way I see it, MusicBrainz collects the metadata of official and
bootleg releases and whatnot.
One thing we do not do is adding my personal best 13 tracks ever
compilation in the database, which I selected for my car cd-player.
Why not?
Because it is of no use to anybody else!
IMHO with
Now that there has been some discussion I've remade the edit at
http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=8756845, vote as you will. If
someone feels that the there is more to add to either side of the
argument (I don't really) then I can cancel the edit.
Philip
On 5/10/08, Bram van Dijk [EMAIL
yes, i realise this. this is not a problem for a database, though, and
the interface for such a facility would have to be completely redone
anyway so you could easily allow this.
2008/5/9 Brian Schweitzer [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
I don't - we'll end up then having to allow the same discID several
Brian Schweitzer skrev:
I don't - we'll end up then having to allow the same discID several
times on the same release as well. It's quite possible and far from
rare for the same CD master, generating the same toc, to be reused in
different countries, for rereleases, etc.
So? I don't see
On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 7:59 AM, Frederik 'Freso' S. Olesen freso.dk@
gmail.com wrote:
Brian Schweitzer skrev:
I don't - we'll end up then having to allow the same discID several times
on the same release as well. It's quite possible and far from rare for the
same CD master, generating the
In this case it isn't very hard to determine for a human, but a script
can't determine it at all since there is no legit discid to compare
with. As for all the other cruft discids, while a script might do a
good job at finding candidates, human intervention will always be
needed and if someone
Proposal:
Change the wording
From: Use a colon (:) to separate multi-line parts of a ReleaseTitle.
to: Use a colon (:) to separate parts of a ReleaseTitle
Where:
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/SubTitleStyle
Why:
1) It unnecessarily restricts http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/ReleaseTitle
where the
+1
On Sat, 2008-05-10 at 17:44 +0200, Lauri Watts wrote:
Proposal:
Change the wording
From: Use a colon (:) to separate multi-line parts of a ReleaseTitle.
to: Use a colon (:) to separate parts of a ReleaseTitle
Where:
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/SubTitleStyle
Why:
1) It
Mos' def.
Chad / voice
Lauri Watts wrote:
Proposal:
Change the wording
From: Use a colon (:) to separate multi-line parts of a ReleaseTitle.
to: Use a colon (:) to separate parts of a ReleaseTitle
Where:
http://wiki.musicbrainz.org/SubTitleStyle
Why:
1) It unnecessarily restricts
2008/5/10 Brian Schweitzer [EMAIL PROTECTED]:
On Sat, May 10, 2008 at 7:59 AM, Frederik 'Freso' S. Olesen
If we could figure that that 1996 Brazilian release's toc was the one with
funky times, sure, that could be helpful. So, I could maybe see why it
might be useful for people to attach
10 matches
Mail list logo
