Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Daniel J. Matyola
I am still puzzled by the Pentax review process. I just had three images that were held under review for 2 weeks after others submitted at the same time were declined. Yesterday, all three were declined, and one that was submitted less than 2 weeks ago was approved. Ann, I suggest that you

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Ann Sanfedele
Dan... Intersting point about the thumbnails... while I might rescan to get a better quality file (and/or not go the route of scaling them down myself just for my submissions) I'm not inclined to crop anything, especially from this collection, just to get in that gallery. Nor would I change

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Ann Sanfedele
Replying to myself to edit this comment: Ann Sanfedele wrote: I'm glad that the thumbnails are seen in the correct proportion on that site, though. I don't understand at all why when a good 90% of photogs (just guessing here, but it seems so) are producing their original images in othe

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Daniel J. Matyola
Although the thumbnails are properly proportioned in the voting process, once an image is placed in the gallery, it gets a square thumbnail. One of my favorite images, the Garden Walk from Villa San Michelle on Capri, make the gallery on the first submission. Now, the thumbnail now on the

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Ann Sanfedele
ah but your landscape oriented ones are not square nor are mine. seems jsut to mess up verticals ann Daniel J. Matyola wrote: Although the thumbnails are properly proportioned in the voting process, once an image is placed in the gallery, it gets a square thumbnail. One of my favorite

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Daniel J. Matyola
True. I find that some of my rejections relate to the purpose of the image. I had two diner interiors that I really love rejected by Pentax. That made me take a hard look at them. They were taken for my diner blog, and both the original exposure and the modifications in PhotoShop were done

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Mark Roberts
On Tue, 8 Mar 2011 16:52:07 -0500, you wrote: True. I find that some of my rejections relate to the purpose of the image. It helps to always remember that the purpose of the Pentax Photo Gallery is to sell camera gear. -- PDML Pentax-Discuss Mail List PDML@pdml.net

RE: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Bob W
[...] I think that the challenge of getting image that I like in the Pentax Gallery serves a useful purpose, by making me rethink my decisions about an image I like and trying to find ways to improve it and give it broader appeal. Dan that's a very worthwhile attitude to take to this

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Daniel J. Matyola
Well, I never discard the original that I made to suit my own tastes or for my diner blog or travel blog. Different versions for different purposes. Re-editing for the PPG is an educational process for me, just like posting PESOs here are reviewing the comments and suggestions. I am old enough,

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-08 Thread Ann Sanfedele
Daniel J. Matyola wrote: Well, I never discard the original that I made to suit my own tastes or for my diner blog or travel blog. Different versions for different purposes. Re-editing for the PPG is an educational process for me, just like posting PESOs here are reviewing the comments and

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-07 Thread Boris Liberman
On 3/6/2011 9:36 PM, Bob W wrote: whoever rejected those doesn't know a good photo from a bite on the ass. B Despite being probably another example of Her Majesty Lingva, I totally agree with Bob's sentiment. These are excellent photos, Ann. Whereas in any such gallery like PPG the

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-07 Thread David J Brooks
Enjoyed them all. You was robbed., Dave 2011/3/6 Ann Sanfedele ann...@nyc.rr.com: The first 7 photos here were dropped  into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back-in-the-day/5908739_3pLhP None of the others that you can see

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-07 Thread David Mann
On Mar 8, 2011, at 12:26 AM, Boris Liberman wrote: Whereas in any such gallery like PPG the decisions are made just by a few individuals, whose idea of what a good photograph is may be, well, let me say - somewhat distorted. If I had my way it'd be all cat photos. Dave -- PDML

Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Ann Sanfedele
The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back-in-the-day/5908739_3pLhP None of the others that you can see here were submitted (I hid a couple from view that were still up there waiting for

RE: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Bob W
From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Ann Sanfedele The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back-in- the-day/5908739_3pLhP I think that tells us

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Ann Sanfedele
Bob W wrote: From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Ann Sanfedele The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back-in- the-day/5908739_3pLhP I think that

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Paul Stenquist
Some excellent photos there. The Pentax Gallery criteria is hard to predict, although over-saturated landscapes seem to be a shoe-in. Paul On Mar 6, 2011, at 12:59 PM, Ann Sanfedele wrote: Bob W wrote: From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Ann

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread P. J. Alling
I rather like the ironic whimsy of the Criminal Courts Building - 1980 with it's unintended admonishment to Lead a clean life. On 3/6/2011 12:37 PM, Ann Sanfedele wrote: The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-(

RE: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Bob W
From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Ann Sanfedele The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back- in- the-day/5908739_3pLhP I think that

Re: Geso - Salon des Refusés

2011-03-06 Thread Ann Sanfedele
Bob W wrote: From: pdml-boun...@pdml.net [mailto:pdml-boun...@pdml.net] On Behalf Of Ann Sanfedele The first 7 photos here were dropped into my Declined folder on the PPG :-( http://annsan.smugmug.com/On-the-Road-or-On-Foot/New-York-City-back- in-