Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-17 Thread Boris Liberman
If I understand you correctly (which is not 100% certain), the front element of my DA* 16-50 exhibits similar behavior. Never noticed it before and never saw any bad image quality that I could attribute to such movements... I must say, Larry, that when I first read the headline of the message,

Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-17 Thread Bob Sullivan
My FA70-200/4-5.6, the power zoom one for the PZ-1, had a wobbly front element. It drove me nuts, but never seemed to affect image quality. It was/is a good lens. Regards, Bob S. On Sat, Nov 17, 2012 at 3:41 PM, Joseph McAllister wrote: > Loose barrels on AF lenses have been discussed since the

Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-17 Thread Joseph McAllister
Loose barrels on AF lenses have been discussed since the "F" days. I first heard of it (and noticed on mine) in the "FA" era with my PZ-1p. Supposed to have no impact on image quality. The official reason for this is the AF motors did not have the power to focus a lens against the drag of what u

Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-15 Thread John Sessoms
My FAJ 18-35 does this. It's noticeably sloppier than the 18-55 kit lens, and gave proportionately disappointing results. From: Bruce Walker This rocking distance is less than a hair's width, right? Mine has always done that, from new. If you push on the front, eg against the lens hood, it clunk

Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-15 Thread Bruce Walker
This rocking distance is less than a hair's width, right? Mine has always done that, from new. If you push on the front, eg against the lens hood, it clunks ever so slightly and you can see and feel lateral movement, but it's a sub-millimeter distance. I assume it's because plastic can't be machine

Re: My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-15 Thread P. J. Alling
There's a certain looseness in all auto-focus lenses. I don't know if that behavior is normal for the 16-50 but I've never seen it reported before. On 11/15/2012 11:51 AM, Larry Colen wrote: I was cleaning my 16-50 this morning and noticed an odd clicking. It turns out that the front elemen

My 16-50 front element rocks

2012-11-15 Thread Larry Colen
I was cleaning my 16-50 this morning and noticed an odd clicking. It turns out that the front element, actually the whole barrel that the front element is in, will rock back and forth a small, but noticeable amount. Is this normal? Does this happen with other people's lenses? I'm going to hop