RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-23 Thread kirstima
mailto:kirst...@saunalahti.fi] Sent: 14-Feb-18 14:23 To: PEIRCE L Subject: RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures) Gary f., list, Your response presented as full an understanding of essential points in my post as I could ever hope. Even more, I was greatly and happily s

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-16 Thread gnox
:23 To: PEIRCE L Subject: RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures) Gary f., list, Your response presented as full an understanding of essential points in my post as I could ever hope. Even more, I was greatly and happily surprised. And yes, of course there are

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-14 Thread Jerry Rhee
“recreated” the symbol by >>> reformulating it, “replicating” it in different ways, and thus >>> taken its expression a step or two further. That’s part of what I >>> call a genuine _argument_ (as opposed to a debate, which is a kind of >>> context between two fixed positio

Re: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-14 Thread Jon Alan Schmidt
Universe is “an argument”, “a vast representamen >> … working out its conclusions in living realities” (EP2:193-4, CP >> 5.119). >> >> I hope you don’t find this presumptuous. At least I can assure you >> that it’s been formulated with some care, including careful >&g

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-14 Thread kirstima
.ca/wp/ [2] }{ _Turning Signs_ gateway -Original Message- From: kirst...@saunalahti.fi [mailto:kirst...@saunalahti.fi] Sent: 14-Feb-18 08:14 To: PEIRCE L Subject: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures) List, First I wish to express my appreciation to Gary f., to hi

RE: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-14 Thread gnox
[mailto:kirst...@saunalahti.fi] Sent: 14-Feb-18 08:14 To: PEIRCE L Subject: [PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures) List, First I wish to express my appreciation to Gary f., to his lead and his commentaries on LL. - However, it seem to me that the discussions tend to

[PEIRCE-L] Pragmatic Maxims and mediation (Was Lowell Lectures)

2018-02-14 Thread kirstima
List, First I wish to express my appreciation to Gary f., to his lead and his commentaries on LL. - However, it seem to me that the discussions tend to get muddled on certain very, very basic respects. Peirce's first formulation of the Pragmatic Maxims was about "practical bearings". So it w