Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread Patrick in VT
On Thursday, October 11, 2012 7:39:42 PM UTC-4, grant wrote: Visit nusi.org. We can guess, but they will discover. I visited. The Board of Directors biographies are telling. Private Equity + Consulting + Pharmaceutical = drug development. Anybody want to bet against that? -- You

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread charlie
The scientific board of advisors, the general advisory board and the board of directors are all well educated credentialed people from a variety of backgrounds. Seventeen people so far I mean who else would be better a butcher, baker and candlestick maker? Perhaps these folks are

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread Patrick in VT
On Friday, October 12, 2012 9:38:00 AM UTC-4, charlie wrote: The scientific board of advisors, the general advisory board and the board of directors are all well educated credentialed people from a variety of backgrounds. I wish I could see the good in it, Charlie - I really do. but I

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread PATRICK MOORE
More data to confuse the issue: http://www.theawl.com/2012/10/the-sugar-wars Note that the report refers to a debate more particularly on sugared sodas, but it does show that the leading scientists are still very uncertain about the fundamental causes of obesity *in our society* (the latter is

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread charlie
On Friday, October 12, 2012 8:18:38 AM UTC-7, Patrick Moore wrote: More data to confuse the issue: http://www.theawl.com/2012/10/the-sugar-wars Here is something interesting, this is from a Vegan site..although it is found elsewhere and is common knowledge and historical fact.

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-12 Thread charlie
Ummm just ate chicken and rainbow chard from our garden with a big green saladnothing wrong with thinking critically. If NUSI merely does the research and brings a drug to help fight obesity in the truly obese then fine. A 500 pound man may benefit from something like that.if in

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread Patrick in VT
On Thursday, October 11, 2012 1:30:19 AM UTC-4, Patrick Moore wrote: Don't be silly. Be reasonable. There are millions of people worldwide who happily and healthily eat diets largely composed of carbs with few health problems. Please don't be totalitarian. Exactly. blaming carbs in the

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread Peter Morgano
Patrick is right, food and calories in general are an economy of scale, where small decisions can add up to something huge down the road, whether for the better or worse. And while I am a political person I really hate to bring up politics or religion with people I don't know that well but I have

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Just for the record, I don't doubt the word of those who *have* benefited from the so-called Primal diet. It just seems that there is overwhelming evidence that it isn't necessary for very many people. Peter and Patrick bring up and interesting point, that there may be more going on with food

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread PATRICK MOORE
To be precise: I mean that there are (empirically) huge number of people for whom it obviously isn't necessary. I don't presume to judge the fraction of people for whom it isn't beneficial or for whom it is. On Thu, Oct 11, 2012 at 9:42 AM, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: It just

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread PATRICK MOORE
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inuit_diet#Nutrition The typical Inuit diet is high in protein and very high in fat – in their traditional diets, Inuit consumed an average of 75% of their daily energy intake from fat.[32] (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inuit#Diet) The footnote refers to this:

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread grant
Visit nusi.org. We can guess, but they will discover. On Sunday, October 7, 2012 11:08:18 PM UTC-7, Tim McNamara wrote: The point of moderation is to prevent problems. Once you've already got problems, it may be a different story. However, extremity in seeking weight loss may not be a

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
If nothing else, I think we can all agree that people who eat low-carb diets tend to look good riding lugged steel, especially if twine and feathers and tweed are part of the ensemble. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread charlie
Thanks Grant..I was beginning to get discouraged in this thread and was ready to abandon my efforts from the past year and a half and just go back to eating carbohydrates again, gaining back all the fat I lost since it obviously doesn't work. I figured I'd just count calories again and eat

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread jimD
I don't always eschew carbohydrates, I do look very good on my Rivendell! …and, oh, umm, I wear a helmet... cause it holds my mirror. -JimD Come to think of it, we should talk about mirrors, those should generate some heat and light along with incredible insights. On Oct 11, 2012, at 6:12 PM,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread Peter Morgano
Why does one mirror on a bike look ok but two makes a bike look like Pee Wee Herman should be riding it, while all cars just come with two? On Thu, Oct 11, 2012 at 11:01 PM, jimD rasterd...@comcast.net wrote: I don't always eschew carbohydrates, I do look very good on my Rivendell! …and, oh,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread Mojo
I want to thank you Grant for bringing Gary Taubes' book and the idea of low-carb diet into my world view. It has been life changing for me. I am not taking statins today because of you Grant. I am 18lbs lighter than before. My blood numbers are much improved. Maybe most importantly I have a

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-11 Thread jimD
Zowie, woulda thunk it? I could put two mirrors on my helmet - one right, one left. Would probably get a head ache and end up cross eyed. -JimD On Oct 11, 2012, at 8:19 PM, Peter Morgano wrote: Why does one mirror on a bike look ok but two makes a bike look like Pee Wee Herman should be

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread charlie
I don't disagree but without and actual change in what one eats (if trying to lose fat) this doesn't work. I haven't stopped doing any of those things heck we don't even have television...A holistic approach is definitely important but the basic fact is about what and how much of it we

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread Peter Morgano
All good points but the issues I at least find in my life are bigger than just wanting to change or doing things differently. Me and my wife get up at 7 and dont get back home from work until 6:30, then we eat dinner with our daughter, do homework and bed time. By then it is 8:30-9pm and everyone

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread Lyle Bogart
the problem for alot of us is we are in a society that demands we work 50 hours a week and keep up a working family unit AND look great all the time and just something has to give +1 On 10 October 2012 10:04, Peter Morgano uscpeter11...@gmail.com wrote: All good points but the issues I at

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Good point, Peter. When you have demoralizing and therefore fatiguing industrialized work that has been broken down into inevitably dissatisfying unintelligible fragments -- true even of much white collar work -- combined with an agressive search for efficiency-for-profit that requires overwork

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread Patrick in VT
On Wednesday, October 10, 2012 9:46:46 AM UTC-4, charlie wrote: I don't disagree but without and actual change in what one eats (if trying to lose fat) this doesn't work. On Wednesday, October 10, 2012 9:46:46 AM UTC-4, charlie wrote: I don't disagree but without and actual change in what

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread charlie
I don't doubt Ernest was depressed and it is quite an achievement to lose 200 pounds (me only 90 total) and I don't doubt the mind, body, lifestyle thing all have to work together.. I do believe however that eating carbohydrates does drive your blood sugar up causing the yo yo effect

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread charlie
Oh by the way I had 90 lbs. to lose total and so far 30 of it isgone for over a year and a half. Weight hasn't gone up but progress has stalled for me due to the compromise that I mentioned earlier.some stressful family situations haven't made it easier. For now I am happy to maintain where

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread Bertin753
Again, not to be annoying, this applies to some people and not for others. Patrick Moore iPhone On Oct 10, 2012, at 9:12 PM, charlie cl_v...@hotmail.com wrote: I don't doubt Ernest was depressed and it is quite an achievement to lose 200 pounds (me only 90 total) and I don't doubt the mind,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread charlie
Yes Patrick, If you are a leaned out super stud with no health problems due to your diet you may rest on the knowledge that you are invincible ; ) Ride on brutha its all good. On Wednesday, October 10, 2012 8:25:16 PM UTC-7, Patrick Moore wrote: Again, not to be annoying, this

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-10 Thread Bertin753
Don't be silly. Be reasonable. There are millions of people worldwide who happily and healthily eat diets largely composed of carbs with few health problems. Please don't be totalitarian. Patrick Moore iPhone On Oct 10, 2012, at 11:21 PM, charlie cl_v...@hotmail.com wrote: Yes Patrick,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-09 Thread Michael Hechmer
Thanks Charlie. I haven't read Grant's book, perhaps because after so many years with the Reader I felt I didn't need to. Maybe I was wrong about that. I hadn't intended to reignite a debate about diet. I understand that some people seem to do pretty well on a fairly high grain/ hi carb

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-09 Thread Lyle Bogart
Michael, In the past I've specifically trained for specific atheletic endeavors such as technical rock and ice climbing, marathon running, and olympic-style weightlifting. In those days, training occurred at a high intensity, often for hours on end, daily. In technical climbing and the sport of

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-09 Thread Lyle Bogart
The DPT after my name is officially for doctor of physical therapy, but in the real world it signified Damned Poor Typist. this: . . . looked at 5 body fat of elite. . . should be . . . looked at % body fat of elite. . . Sheesh. . . lyle On 9 October 2012 07:11, Lyle Bogart

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-09 Thread Patrick in VT
On Monday, October 8, 2012 12:36:23 PM UTC-4, franklyn wrote: There is a whole community of people who were inspired by Bill Clinton's weight loss based on a lifestyle and diet changes . .. Bill Clinton aside, lifestyle is a very important part of the equation. There's a lot of talk about

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-09 Thread RJM
Get busy living or get busy dying. On Tuesday, October 9, 2012 9:43:43 AM UTC-5, Patrick in VT wrote: On Monday, October 8, 2012 12:36:23 PM UTC-4, franklyn wrote: There is a whole community of people who were inspired by Bill Clinton's weight loss based on a lifestyle and diet changes .

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Tim McNamara
The point of moderation is to prevent problems. Once you've already got problems, it may be a different story. However, extremity in seeking weight loss may not be a good plan either. I have known people who developed health problems as a result of the Adkins plan, the primal type stuff, etc.

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
I have lots to say about this. I'll try to be concise. Extreme is a loaded term, and may in fact be meaningless. For the duration of the television age, at least, we've been advised by the slickest marketers on earth to avoid the fat and cholesterol of eggs in favor of the whole grain goodness

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread charlie
Well stated Jim and Grant, its where I was coming from more or less.I hear the moderation suggestion all the time and like you Jim it just doesn't work for me. I also believe some try to sabotage my efforts subconsciously by offering up the moderation idea and frankly its a little annoying

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
This is veering off into lala land. I think that we might agree on the following: 1. Moderation! In our opinions. 2. It seems to be clear that Primal works for some people, at least for some things -- maybe for all things, that is, maybe there are no down sides to the benefits for these people,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Steve Palincsar
On Mon, 2012-10-08 at 07:59 -0600, PATRICK MOORE wrote: 5. Let's leave evolution and cave men out of it. To explain Primal or anything else by supposing we know what our distant ancestors did is to attempt to explain the still-not-completely-known by the entirely conjectural. Bravo! Very

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
I think it was Taubes who said something to the effect of: if you're fat, it's because of carbs. People who aren't fat are excluded by the first half of the sentence, so all those rice-eating thin Chinese people need not apply. I've never seen a fat person on the city bus snacking on bacon and

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
There was plenty of protein and fat in this diet: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Super_Size_Me Along with huge amounts of starch, of course. It would be interesting to discover (1) the breakdown of starch/fat/protein/what else? and (2) discover what made him gain 24 lb, starch only or fat too?

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Forgot to include demographics close to home: Fat Hopi, Zuni, Navajo etc. exquisitely inclined to diabetes after they left their traditional squash/corn/ beans/game/mutton diets for refined carbs 'n' lard. (I've seen families at the checkout counter with the standard 20 lb cloth bags of bleached

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Jim Thill - Hiawatha Cyclery
The Supersize Me guy was remarkable for not only eating fast food for every meal, but for eating an extraordinary quantity of it. It seems that he likely consumed at least 500 cal of pure sugar or HFCS for every single meal. This is in addition to the non-sugar carbs, protein, and fat. My

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread Leslie
Once upon a time, 20 years ago, I was a skinny 6', 145lb Marine... But after learning how to eat everything I could get my hands on, then getting out of constant activity and sitting on my duff for years of grad school, I found myself 10 years ago tipping the scales at 280lbs... I went on a

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread franklyn
There is a whole community of people who were inspired by Bill Clinton's weight loss based on a lifestyle and diet changes expressed in the documentary forks over knives and benefited from a switch to a HEALTHY plant-based diet. I stress the word HEALTHY because based on my own experience of

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread charlie
Forget the running unless you are doing short intense interval sprints..better to lift weights if you want to lose fat. Perhaps a read of Grants latest book will school you all on the subject. It really is a good book and he touches in a basic way the principles for losing fat and proper

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Someone said: Patrick ( and Jim), Tying your two thoughts together on alcohol: when I had the opportunity to spend a week in Albuquerque this past summer, I was shocked at the quantity of cheap liquor available even in WalMart there And noting the sizes of those purchasers buying in quantity,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread James Warren
May I steal this phrase, and use it in my own conversations? It is brilliant! On Oct 8, 2012, at 7:05 PM, PATRICK MOORE wrote: but wine is from heaven and must not be neglected. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-08 Thread PATRICK MOORE
I was just now reading an essay about the life, works and influence of Woodie Guthrie (here if you want it: http://chronicle.com/article/Woody-Guthrie-at-100/134838/) In a 1999 essay, Seeger recalled that his friend's view of copyright was not exactly exclusive, and ran something like this:

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-07 Thread charlie
] That Diet and Exercise thing again! I can't cite evidence except long-term and widespread custom, but while it may well be true that effective insulin regulation is the -- or *a* -- key to good metabolism, I can't help but think that 10,000 years of agriculture -- ie, grains -- can't help

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-07 Thread Lyle Bogart
] Sent: Saturday, October 06, 2012 3:08 PM To: rbw-owne...@googlegroups.**com Subject: Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again! I can't cite evidence except long-term and widespread custom, but while it may well be true that effective insulin regulation is the -- or *a* -- key to good

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-07 Thread charlie
Subject: Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again! I can't cite evidence except long-term and widespread custom, but while it may well be true that effective insulin regulation is the -- or *a* -- key to good metabolism, I can't help but think that 10,000 years of agriculture -- ie, grains

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-07 Thread Tim McNamara
Too much of anything is bad for you. Too many carbs, too much fat, too much protein, too much water, too much alcohol, too much exercise, too much laziness, too much stress, etc. Humans are omnivorous in many ways and can thrive in an amazing variety of situations. Moderation in all things,

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-07 Thread charlie
Kind of agree and kind of don't...(for some) trying to lose fat, moderation amounts to no progress. For those people it takes absolute vigilance and resolve without any wavering to lose fat and maintain their effort. Compromise just doesn't end well ultimately. Maybe for the average person

[RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-06 Thread Michael Hechmer
This may be stretching the boundaries of the list mission, but we have entertained a long discussion around Why We Get Fat, and if memory serves me right, GP published an article in the Reader, which challenged the wisdom of extreme forms of exercise, like the Iron Man competition. So... I

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-06 Thread Lyle Bogart
I learned about Mark Sisson through Grant's writings. After looking into it, it appeared to be a refinement of what I do nutritionally anyway (I don't forego carbs to the extent that Sisson does--can't give up baking my own bread!). I find that the closer I adhere to Sisson's points, the more even

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-06 Thread PATRICK MOORE
I can't cite evidence except long-term and widespread custom, but while it may well be true that effective insulin regulation is the -- or *a* -- key to good metabolism, I can't help but think that 10,000 years of agriculture -- ie, grains -- can't help but be natural to the human body (dig the

RE: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-06 Thread Marc Schwartz
, October 06, 2012 3:08 PM To: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again! I can't cite evidence except long-term and widespread custom, but while it may well be true that effective insulin regulation is the -- or *a* -- key to good metabolism, I can't

Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again!

2012-10-06 Thread PATRICK MOORE
From: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com [rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com] on behalf of PATRICK MOORE [bertin...@gmail.com] Sent: Saturday, October 06, 2012 3:08 PM To: rbw-owners-bunch@googlegroups.com Subject: Re: [RBW] That Diet and Exercise thing again! I can't cite evidence except long