RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Matthew Rosenblum
John,   Under HIPAA, a pharmacist’s job is to provide direct treatment services and to use and disclose related PHI in accordance with the privacy, security and TCS rules.  So  if a pharmacist needs to consult with other CE’s in the neighbor (or to contact government offficials) to pro

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Christiansen, John (SEA)
Hate to say it, but I disagree: Under HIPAA a pharmacist's job is to establish and comply with certain policies for privacy, security and electronic claims processing. It is a pharmacist's *professional* obligation to avoid (or mitigate) harm to individuals, and HIPAA is not intended to *int

Re: HIPAA privacy and telephone

2003-01-16 Thread Ellen Rubin
At our hospital we are stating the following in training: "Our general policy would be to not give information out over the phone except to the patient. However, in certain clinics and inpatient units, staff will be familiar with the caller and with the patient's usual wishes. Staff will be able t

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Matthew Rosenblum
Tim,   I must respectfully disagree with your fundamental analysis of this scenario.  Pharmacists (chemists) have, for more than 2000 years, been part of a triad (including physicians and nurses) engaged in an on-going clinical (NOT business) practice of ensuring that the correct medicati

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Matthew Rosenblum
Tim,   I must respectfullly disagree with your fundamental analysis of this scenario.  Pharmacists (chemists) have, for more than 2000 years, been part of a triad (including physicians and nurses) engaged in an on-going clinical (NOT business) practice of ensuring that the correct medi

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Christiansen, John (SEA)
The magnitude of the crime does not trigger a change in legal treatment. 45 CFR 164.512(f)(5) permits CEs to disclose PHI to law enforcement if the CE "believes in good faith constitutes evidence of criminal conduct that occurred on the premises of the covered entity," and sub (6) permits pr

Re: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Hcs321
John: Thank you so much for your detailed reply, though I am afraid I do not concur with your answer. The point in discussion was an obvious abuse of the system; any other drug would not detain the wrath of the law BUT NARCOTICS DOES. Reference to rights was only associated with this particular cr

RE: HIPAA privacy and telephone

2003-01-16 Thread Matthew Rosenblum
Fairley, I believe that leaving the "message" (in your scenario, below) would be a HIPAA-sanctioned disclosure if the nurse has evidence that the spouse is: The Personal Representative of the subject of the PHI, or Participating in the patient's treatment Otherwise, probably not. Furthe

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Christiansen, John (SEA)
Very true, there does seem to be a trend toward federal agencies assuming the legal discretion to suspend or eliminate rights of non-US citizens in the US, and also perhaps US citizen "combatants" as well, and at least seeming to claim that they have the authority to determine whether such i

HIPAA privacy and telephone

2003-01-16 Thread Fairley2
I would like the lists opinion on this topic. Patient comes to the office to have their potassium checked because they are on a diuretic. Later, the physician's nurse calls the patient at home with results but the patient is not home. Spouse answers the phone. Can you tell the spouse that the

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread timmcguinness
In my personal opinion, this practice - violating patient privacy, in the name of detecting abuse by private businesses - which is (it appears to me) unsupported by statute (unless mandated by DEA regulation) - is contrary to both many state laws and HIPAA.  I agree the practice serves a val

RE: Board of Directors - Workforce or Business Associates?

2003-01-16 Thread Matthew Rosenblum
Leslie,   A Corporation's charter and bylaws would "control" how the Board may function.  Consequently, the Board could be construed as part of the workforce.   Further, in the Preamble to the (initial) Final Privacy rules, HHS notes that, "independent contractors may or may not be w

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread David Frenkel
John, I think there is some evolution going on in this area in regards to non-US citizens who are arrested in the US.  Congress passed legislation that allows the INS to hold non-US citizens arrested of any crime without bail.  The evolution appears to be that these non-US citizens whethe

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Rebekah Savoie
Thank you for all your responses. They were all great and exactly what I expected - Now I will tell you the rest of the story - A man stole some Rx books and forged the Rx's - but it gets better - he used someone else's name and the pharmacy gave this information to physicians when the person t

RE: Documents

2003-01-16 Thread Line, Phyllis
Title: RE: Documents I would also be interested if such things are available. Please contact me off line at [EMAIL PROTECTED] Thanks! Phyllis Line HIPAA Privacy Officer HEREIU Welfare Pension Funds 630-236-5114 [EMAIL PROTECTED] -Original Message- From: Joe Smith [mailto:[EMAI

RE: Board of Directors - Workforce or Business Associates?

2003-01-16 Thread Leslie C Bender
How are organizations classifying Board of Directors or Trustee members?  Workforce -- or since they are not "under the direction" of the covered entity, but have a need from time to time, to receive PHI, or might they better be classified as “business associates” and need a business assoc

RE: Sample NPP for SFGHPs

2003-01-16 Thread Line, Phyllis
I too would be interested in this type of sample.   Phyllis Line HIPAA Privacy Officer HEREIU Welfare Pension Funds 630-236-5114 [EMAIL PROTECTED]   -Original Message-From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]]Sent: Wednesday, January 15, 2003 7:50 AMTo: WEDI SNIP P

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Christiansen, John (SEA)
Robert -   I think I need to question one of your assumptions, and your approach to this kind of problem.    #1 the assumption that:   is not correct, and is in fact dangerously incorrect.   HIPAA does not state that principle anywhere. It does list a number of conditions under which PHI m

RE: Privacy: de-identification analysis (no safe harbor)

2003-01-16 Thread Clay, Roy III (NO)
Title: RE: Privacy: de-identification analysis (no safe harbor) You may want to check with your local university if they have a school of public health. The biostatistics department should have the means to provide you with that analysis. -Original Message- From: Tim Belcheck [mailto

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Drexler, Deborah (EHS)
It's sounds logical that a person loses privacy rights when they break the law.  But I'm not sure the assertion is supported by the language of the rule.  Certainly, there is an exception for disclosures to law enforcement, but this exists whether or not the person broke the law.  And inmate

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Drexler, Deborah (EHS)
  It's sounds logical that a person loses privacy rights when they break the law.  But I'm not sure the assertion is supported by the language of the rule.  Certainly, there is an exception for disclosures to law enforcement, but this exists whether or not the person broke the law.  And inma

Re: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Hcs321
Yes and no. First, they are breaking the law when they doctor-shop for narcotics. Secondly, who is responsible for report this to law enforcement? The question comes up, how did you know the individual went to different pharmacies? were you told by the same chain of pharmacies? Usually it will b

Re: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Hcs321
Yes and no. First, they are breaking the law when they doctor-shop for narcotics. Secondly, who is responsible for report this to law enforcement? The question comes up, how did you know the individual went to different pharmacies? were you told by the same chain of pharmacies? Usually it will be t

Re: FW: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Hcs321
In my humble opinion, this would be allowed under PTO. Robert Robert Blinch-Edwards Executive Director Healthcare Sarasota, Inc. 1991 Main Street, Suite 148 Sarasota, FL 34236 Tel: 941-917-7995 Fax: 941-917-1930 email: [EMAIL PROTECTED] Web: www.hcsrq.com --- The WEDI SNIP listserv to which you

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Drexler, Deborah (EHS)
Title: RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems Roy, I find that I must respectfully disagree with your second sentence below    "PHI" refers to information not only about someone's health status, but also information related to the past, present or future *payment* for hea

Privacy: de-identification analysis (no safe harbor)

2003-01-16 Thread Tim Belcheck
There may be situations in which clients cannot comply with the safe harbor for determining whether information is de-identified. In such a case, we would perform the analysis required by Section 164.514(b)(1). I would like to build a database of names of experts in the field of statistics a

FW: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Smith, Patricia
It's not just narcotics. Some pharmacies are doing something similar with drug interactions. If I decide not to go to my PCP for a particular problem I'm having, and the new doctor prescribes a medication that interacts adversely with medication my PCP prescribed, the pharmacy is notifying both

RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems

2003-01-16 Thread Clay, Roy III (NO)
Title: RE: Here is a good Privacy Issue that will cause problems I would argue that releasing information that a patient has been restricted to one pharmacy is not a disclosure under HIPAA. A disclosure must contain a person's identifying information and information on their health status. I d