On Thursday 09 Jun 2005 15:35, Daniel Carrera wrote:
> Tim Fairchild wrote:
> > Although some wish to call it a cult, the church of scientology is
> > considered a religion by a great many people apparently. At least
> > according to google.
>
> Look, scientologists calling scientology a religion doesn't make it so.
> The word "religion" has a definition somewhere. Scientology is not
> recognized as a religion.

I 'believe' in religious tollerance and if they want to call it a religion or 
an "applied religious philosophy" then it's fine with me. I don't see it as a 
big deal. A lot of people on the net, such as those supporting religious 
tollerance, call it a religion, even tho they are not scientologists... But 
getting OT a bit :) 

> > To me personally, all supernatural belief is very similar, yes. Some
> > people believe John Edward talks to dead people, some believe in voodoo,
>
> Well, if you are going to call everything that involves faith "religion"
> then that word wouldn't mean that much. But fact is "religion" and
> "faith" are different, and not all faiths are religions. If you black
> cats and bad luck a religion then I guess I see why you consider the
> force a religion too. But that's not what the word religion means.

I looked up several definitions of religion and jedi and scientology seem 
covered under some of the definitions. Note, a belief in a black cat may not 
be a religion, but I already conceded that. But what about a belief system 
like voodoo? What about the Inuit? Do they have a religion? What about the 
Australian Aboriginal?

tim

-- 
---------------------------------------------------------
  Tim & Therese Fairchild
  Atchafalaya Border Collies.
  Kuttabul, Queensland, Australia.
---------------------------------------------------------
 Email       mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED]
 Homepage    http://www.bcs4me.com
 Photos      http://www.pbase.com/amosf
---------------------------------------------------------

Reply via email to