There two other methods that you can try:
1. Right-click on the Inbox folder, select 'Rebuild Summary File'.
If that doesn't work:
2. Close SeaMonkey and delete (or better yet, rename) the inbox .msf
http://seamonkey.ilias.ca/profilefaq/ for the location.
The msf files do not store information on what mail was downloaded.
support-seamonkey mailing list