2014-12-04 16:29 GMT+01:00 althio forum <althio.fo...@gmail.com>: > Second choice: I would like "military". Is the overload of the key > such a no-go... > Third: I'll go for "military_vehicles". >
+1 actually I am not completely sure about the "overload" problem, because we already do it elsewhere (might be a problem there as well), e.g. the key "bus" is not reserved to access-tagging alone, it is also used to declare the type of stop in the public transport alternative tagging (which didn't ultimately manage to takeover). > Martin Koppenhoefer <dieterdre...@gmail.com> wrote: > > no, I'd clearly go for "private_hire" > > For consistency you could consider here: > "private_hire" -> "private_hire_vehicle" or "vehicle_hire_with_driver"? > I am surprised by your choice of "private_hire" because this is the > only case where I find that the definition is too implicit and > requires the additional "_vehicle". Even if the expression "private > hire vehicle" is common, with only "private hire" you could privately > hire anything from cars with or without driver to bicycles and horses > and caravans. > "private hire" seems to be a very established term, you can find something in wikipedia and if you search for it with a searchengine you'll get only pertinent results in the first pages. No "_vehicle" postfix typically. We could add it still, because OSM tags are not only used by natives, but it is definitely longer ;-) > > (4) attempt to modify "access" categories and labels > > Would you care to present a similar version of your ideas? > It would be useful to see how you want to arrange labels and hierarchy > for the categories you are describing. > Maybe on the discussion page like > > http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Talk:Key:access#Draft_of_hierarchy_for_land-based_transportation_mode yes, I think its time to move over to the wiki and set up a proposal. Thanks all for your input, I'll post a link here when I've a draft for the proposal. Cheers, Martin
_______________________________________________ Tagging mailing list Tagging@openstreetmap.org https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
