The counter-argument is that a novice is less likely to break the data
when updating an area that is mapped using associatedStreet. I like
the fact the fact that people need not even be aware of addresses in
order to fix a street name.
I disagree. Awareness is exactly what you need. I destroyed many of them
in the beginning, because I remapped areas andt replaces nodes with the
proper outlines etc.
Being able to add/fix housenumbers without
having to worry about addr:street (which would be very cumbersome on
mobile devices editors - editing while surveying FTW) is also a big
plus.
I really don't get this. If you are able to add house numbers, why would
you be likely to fuck up street names? If at all seeing addr:street when
on the ground is good, because you can be sure it's you are adding it to
the right building and can also fix possible street errors. It's not
like every street relation is perfect. I also don't get what's
cumbersome of having a line for street name on your mobile device editor.
Given that relations in general are not going away, the proper
solution to the "novices have trouble with relations" problem is not
to use less relations but to make relations easyer to edit and better
documented. FWIW, I feel there is slow but steady progress in that
domain.
Considering that we get more and more editors that are specilized on
adding just a certain kind of feature that's not going to happen. Yes,
relations won't go away, but if I make a very simple map and specilaized
editor I can usually ignore them.
One good example is https://openbeermap.github.io/
Adding simple stuff like name and opening hours to a few basic amenities
isn't something that requires you to bother with relations. If they
wanted to inlude addresses then it would be 100x easier for them to just
add 4 lines for the addr: tags which use exactly the same code as the
other already existing fields. With a associatedStreet relation this
would take a lot more effort.
__________
openstreetmap.org/user/AndiG88
wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/User:AndiG88
_______________________________________________
Tagging mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/tagging
