Hello Ludwa6, I also came across an article from https://thesweetsetup.com/the-art-of-note-making-syncing-book-highlights-with-obsidian-and-more/ which is also quite interesting. But thanks for sharing the hackernews thread. A lot of good opinions in there.
ludwa6 schrieb am Freitag, 18. Juni 2021 um 18:36:29 UTC+2: > Came across this article today > <http://blog.dornea.nu/2021/06/13/note-taking-in-2021/> via HackerNews > (where it has sparked quite a lively comment thread > <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27513008>), which brought me to > realise something about an inner tension i have been struggling for too > long to reconcile: it's about the difference between NoteTAKING vs > NoteMAKING (or DigitalGardening or MindMapping or ZettelKasten or PKMS or > whatever you want to call it) -two modalities of work that are so > fundamentally different, the idea of trying to do both with the same tool > might just never work, period. > > Interestingly, author Victor Dorneau keeps his own Zettelkasten in > TiddlyWiki, citing @Soren B's as his inspiration (GMTA ;-)...And tho his > NoteTaking/GTD system is rather more complicated than i would like (it > involves Emacs ORG mode and some proprietary mobile app, from which he > extracts & converts data to XML via a "simple" Golang script), i completely > resonate with the principle: while one's NoteMAKING tool should be > optimised for "Intertwingularity" -as TiddlyWiki of course is- one's > NoteTAKING tool should optimised for maximum speed & portability. > > So, i'm now back to using Dynalist for agile NoteTaking, exporting my > workfile at day's end as plain text, and copy/pasting it into a new Journal > tiddler in TW for integration. Crude, but effective enough, albeit with > some editing overhead in TW that it would be nice to eliminate. Am > starting to explore the possibilities of Logseq as a potential Dynalist > replacement; it does outlining in much the same way, but has some > interesting export functions, including JSON and Roam JSON. If there were > a way in TW to import such exports and convert them into proper tiddlers... > That would be amazing! > > If anyone else has got some other solution for agile NoteTaking that > integrates nicely with TiddlyWiki for NoteMaking, i'd be very interested to > hear about it. > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "TiddlyWiki" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to [email protected]. To view this discussion on the web visit https://groups.google.com/d/msgid/tiddlywiki/74f3d04d-2d2b-42fd-a02e-10145516deb2n%40googlegroups.com.
