I understand where you are coming from but its a "view all" only, or "edit 
all only". I think when using tiddlywiki users and for matter, when acting 
as an application or website, this all or nothing edit approach forces the 
need for total acceptance of the idea of a tiddler. When for many users 
they are thinking about the book review, movie notes, expense record or 
something else, do they really need to see all fields, including  caption, 
color and icon fields if they only want to change a minor detail.

What if all they wish to do is select a due date for the tiddler?, why 
should they open the whole tiddler in edit mode, then have to look for 
where to make the change? when they could simply set the due date?

Whilst I have detailed knowledge of tiddlywiki I need not be an end user to 
want to have simple and direct ways to interact with a tiddler sometimes.

Perhaps "using forms" is a way to describe "custom edits" of a tiddler and 
its attributes, but I see value in letting the designer determine exactly 
which elements can be changed. Perhaps a concept of view, update and edit 
modes or let the difference between view and edit blur so any attribute (eg 
field, tag) of a tiddler can be made available to change/edit.

To me any tiddler can be considered a form, and we can programatically 
decide which attributes can be edited as needed. This is most definitely in 
the case of selecting at least which attributes/fields are visible to the 
user in view mode, because currently most additional fields are not visible.

What are you thoughts on my thinking here?


On Friday, February 2, 2018 at 10:28:15 PM UTC+11, PMario wrote:
> On Friday, February 2, 2018 at 8:10:42 AM UTC+1, TonyM wrote:
>> In any given tiddler have a field called field-view or field-edit which 
>> lists field names that are to be displayed or edited in the view template
> IMO it's named ViewTemplate for a reason. If you need to edit it, 
> EditTemplate should be used. ... 
> May be we need something like a FormTemplate .. That allows "end users" to 
> insert stuff into different tiddlers using Forms.
> just my thought. 
> mario

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"TiddlyWiki" group.
To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email 
To post to this group, send email to
Visit this group at
To view this discussion on the web visit
For more options, visit

Reply via email to