There are just too many places that specialize to turn a Treo specific listserv into an all in one group (which is not its intent). If you want to hear all about the latest in every device, check out http://thecellphonejunkie.com. If you think BB is the be all, end all to cell phones, I hear crackberry.com is nice. But this is a Treo group. The occasional comparisons can't be helped, but do you invite the preacher from the other church to give the guest sermon every week?
Levi Wallach wrote: > Hmmm, I've enjoyed discussions on this group for years, but I don't like > when criticisms of Palm or PalmOS become off-topic. That doesn't seem very > open to me. Now if someone has come on simply to blast and criticize and > that's all they do, well, then that starts sounding like a Troll, but > criticism in and of itself and a debate about another platform being better > than PalmOS, well, that's just open discussion. It is very relevant to > Palm/PalmOS, although Palm/PalmOS adherents may not like to hear such > criticism. What blurs this significantly is that Palm itself has been > selling Windows Mobile devices for a couple of years now under the Treo > brand. So wouldn't the choice of which OS to get on your Treo phone be > relevant? And if that's relevant, why not compare to other platforms? Alli, > maybe you are a comoderator here, I can't remember. I know Craig is. And > whatever you guys say goes, but if you truly are going to censor this group > when PalmOS is criticized (or o the > r platforms are lauded) too much for your taste, to me this becomes a not > particularly open place anymore. Perhaps that's what you want, though, for > this to be a place simply for loyal PalmOS fans, and that's fine, but if > that's the case, please confirm it so those who don't fit this mold can go > elsewhere. > > Levi
