Hash: SHA1

On Thursday May 28, 2009, Henri Yandell wrote:
> On Thu, May 28, 2009 at 5:01 PM, William A. Rowe, Jr.
> <wr...@rowe-clan.net> wrote:
> > Alan D. Cabrera wrote:
> >> Take for example the donation of ServiceMix by LogicBlaze.  LogicBlaze
> >> renamed its product offering of ServiceMix to FUSE.
> >
> > Reread the request!
> >
> > They aren't asking to brand a fork of the software, or similar that you
> > are citing.
> >
> > They are asking if they provide the "VCL Server" will we be mad?
> >
> > No more than if they hosted an "Apache HTTP Server" or "Tomcat Server".
> >
> > If they shipped software they called "VCL" then yes, we would take issue.
> Nope - they're asking if they brand a service "VCL" will we be mad.
> Akin to my setting up a hosting service called "Tomcat" (or DimSum
> Tomcat) that lets people log in and run their own Tomcat servers. Plus
> if I decide to throw out Tomcat and use Jetty instead, I still get to
> call it DimSum Tomcat.
> Hen

Hen is correct about it being a service.  The VCL software is designed to be 
run as a service.  The software was initially developed at NCSU, and they 
have a service that was initially known as "VCL".  As other institutions 
started using the software, NCSU changed their service to be "NCSU VCL" and 
allowed others to brand their services as "<institution name> VCL" (i.e. "GMU 
VCL").  It was assumed that with moving the development of the software to 
ASF, it would be named "Apache VCL" and that people using it would have the 
option to name their services "<institution name> VCL".

There was much discussion on the vcl-...@incubator.a.o list about whether or 
not there were legal issues with that; thus, the discussion was brought up on 

Also, there's a possibility that it may be technically legal, but ASF would 
frown on it.  People at NCSU have thought that using the name Apache VCL 
would bring those that already knew about VCL while it was developed at NCSU 
to the ASF community.  Thus, it has been confusing that an action that was 
motivated by the goal of building Apache VCL community would be frowned upon.  
As a new project that is trying to make it in the ASF Way, we want to avoid 
being frowned upon. :)

Thanks for the guidance,
- -- 
- -------------------------------
Josh Thompson
Systems Programmer
Virtual Computing Lab (VCL)
North Carolina State University


my GPG/PGP key can be found at pgp.mit.edu
Version: GnuPG v1.4.6 (GNU/Linux)


Reply via email to