Paul,

I think what you are alluding to is more correctly called "power"
rather than "energy". Indeed, "power" can be defined without the
concept of "energy".

All you need to express power is force F times velocity v,
*Dimensionally* this has the same units as  [E]/[t],
since [F][v] -> [m][a][v] -> [p]^2/[m][t] -> [m]^2[v]^2/[t]

In first year physics the power needed to lift a weight
is usually presented in terms of force f, the height it is
lifted and the time taken( P = Fd/t = Work/t = E/t)

This gives the _total_ power required, but the significance
of the number lies in the design and completion of a task.
This number might of interest to the person performing
the task or to an energy planner but the machinations
of men are simply incidental to nature.

A quantity that is not incidental to nature
is the instantaneous rate of power consumption.
If the weight being lifted at time t has a velocity
v, then the lifter (man, animal or machine) must have an
instantaneous power consumption rate.

Harry

Reply via email to