On 11-11-28 11:21 AM, Rich Murray wrote:
Joshua Cude has completed his proof that Rossi's own data from the "1 MW" demo shows unavoidably that it is certain that no excess heat was produced. Q.E.D.
Jeeze, Rich, if you're going to post things that boil down to "We are the chorus, and we agree, we agree, we agree!", could you at least try to agree with what was said, rather than what you wish had been said?
Joshua has done a very nice job of showing that the data are consistent with little excess heat having been produced, and with certain additional assumptions, they're consistent with scenarios in which no excess heat was produced.
That is a very far cry from showing "unavoidably" that "it is certain that no excess heat was produced", which is what you morphed his words into.
You, Rich, sound like an anti-Aetherist, bellowing that Einstein proved there is no aether. He didn't; he merely presented a theory which was consistent with observation and which did not *require* an aether. Similarly, Joshua didn't prove there's no excess heat; he merely showed that the evidence for excess heat during the 470kW run is inconclusive.
(And now I really must go back to ignoring this list for another little while....)
