RE: [Vo]:arXiv:1306.6364 Comments on the report "Indications of anomalous heat energy production in a reactor device containing hydrogen loaded nickel powder"

[Jones Beene]

 

 

From: Jed Rothwell 

 

This paper says:

 

We note first of all that the circumstances and people involved in the test
make if far from being an independent one.

 

This is in a physics paper!?! What an outrageous thing to say. Where are
they trying to publish, in the National Enquirer?

 

That's incredible. Outlandish. And completely false.

 

You lose all credibility when you publish this kind of garbage in the guise
of a physics paper. 

 

 

What a pair of arrogant buffoons these two are. 

 

One suspects the intent is to uphold the reputation of the Svedberg
Laboratory, Uppsala University, Sweden; but instead - in looking at their
own lightweight publications and their prior goonish criticism of Cardone -
it seem their main function at this once fine Lab is to act as "enforcer"
(for those of you who understand ice hockey)