See: http://www.infinite-energy.com/iemagazine/issue118/analysis.html
Jed's opinion: I completely agree with everything McKubre says here about the calorimetry. I share his reservations. I agree with the rest of this report except the nuclear theory is partly over my head. No opinion about that. I like this statement: "One experimental result equates to zero experimental results. Nothing in science can be known without repetition." Very true and people often forget it. Or, as I have been saying, definitive experiments only happen in Hollywood movies. McKubre emphasizes the need for more communication from the authors. Yes! That would be a big help. I hope the authors respond to the questions here: http://www.lenr-forum.com/forum/index.php/Thread/722-Ask-questions-to-the-Working-Group-ECAT-long-term-test/ Especially I hope they respond to *my* questions. I will be nervous about this experiment until they say the cell was incandescent white. That is the simplest way to confirm that the temperature really was around 1300°C. The photograph in Fig. 12 shows it around 700°C, judging by the dull red color. See: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Incandescence#mediaviewer/File:Incandescence_Color.jpg I do not know when they took that photo. - Jed
