Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
Frank Nordberg wrote: Just like to tell everybody at abcusers that I've just posted a complete ABC edition of Tielman Susato's Danserye Hey great, thats really nice. My transcriptions raises a few interesting questions regarding ABC-versions of early music. Should we add barlines? How do

P:field [Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes]

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
Hello again, Frank Nordberg wrote: http://www.musicaviva.com/abc/tunes/susato-tielman/susato-1551.abc My transcriptions raises a few interesting questions regarding ABC-versions of early music. Should we add barlines? How do we disern between original and editorial accidentals? etc. etc.

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Phil Taylor
Simon Wascher wrote: Frank Nordberg wrote: Just like to tell everybody at abcusers that I've just posted a complete ABC edition of Tielman Susato's Danserye Hey great, thats really nice. It is indeed - thank you Frank. My transcriptions raises a few interesting questions regarding

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
Hello, Phil Taylor wrote: Simon Wascher wrote: I would find it much better to write the music voice after voice. (...) I disagree. Writing the abc line by line preserves the original music layout in the abc, Not necessarily, especially not if the original layout is no score but single

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Laura Conrad
Simon == Simon Wascher [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Simon I would find it much better to write the music voice after Simon voice. It is not really possible to read the four voices Simon in paralell in the abc text anyway and it is complicate to Simon extract parts for playing.

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Laura Conrad
Phil == Phil Taylor [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: I usually use #A or bA to show editorial accidentals. Phil Yes. Perhaps ^# would be better. Are there any abc2ps variants that have implemented this feature? I still find that programmers should enable voice after voice input. The

[abcusers] V: formatting (was: Susato's Danseryes)

2001-09-04 Thread Frank Nordberg
I post this as a separate thread, since it's a general ABC issue, not specifically a renaissance one: Simon Wascher wrote: ... I would find it much better to write the music voice after voice. It is not really possible to read the four voices in paralell in the abc text anyway and it is

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Jack Campin
I would find it much better to write the music voice after voice. It is not really possible to read the four voices in parallel in the abc text anyway Not unless the source is laid out helpfully, but for this sort of music it can be quite easily. I haven't changed a note in Frank's

Re: P:field [Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes]

2001-09-04 Thread John Chambers
Simon Wascher schrieb: | Why do'nt you use the P:field within the tune body for the Reprise | text? ... | To my personal understanding I always wonder why someone created a field | that organizes the playing order and does not allow the usual part and | playing order terms to be used

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread John Chambers
Laura Conrad asks: | Phil == Phil Taylor [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: | | I usually use #A or bA to show editorial accidentals. | | Phil Yes. Perhaps ^# would be better. | | Are there any abc2ps variants that have implemented this feature? Well, abc2ps has accepted #A and bA

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Laura Conrad
John == John Chambers [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: John Making ^#A work is trivial with abc2ps. You find the code that John parses such quoted chord symbols, and have it ignore an initial John circumflex. This is one line of C. I've done this in my abc2ps clone. John

Re: [abcusers] Advisory accidentals

2001-09-04 Thread Laura Conrad
John == John Chambers [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: John Simon Wascher writes: John | I usually use #A or bA to show editorial accidentals. John I've done this, too. One thing to beware of here is that in some John musical circles, an accental above (or below) the note is

Re: [abcusers] Advisory accidentals

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
Hello, John Chambers wrote: Simon Wascher writes: | I usually use #A or bA to show editorial accidentals. One thing to beware of here is that in some musical circles, an accental above (or below) the note is used to mean just this one note. Its the same with me. For me using #

Re: P:field [Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes]

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
John Chambers wrote: Hello, Simon Wascher schrieb: (...) | $ Example: P:[Einleitung][1.][1.][2.][2.][1.][Ausgang] John Chambers wrote: Less messy would be to just use either of: $ Example: P:Einleitung,1,1,2,2,1,Ausgang $ Example: P:Einleitung 1 1 2 2 1 Ausgang These are

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread John Chambers
Laura writes: | John == John Chambers [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: | John Making ^#A work is trivial with abc2ps. You find the code that | John parses such quoted chord symbols, and have it ignore an initial | John circumflex. This is one line of C. I've done this

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread Simon Wascher
Jack Campin wrote: Simon Wascher wrote: I would find it much better to write the music voice after voice. It is not really possible to read the four voices in parallel in the abc text anyway Not unless the source is laid out helpfully, but for this sort of music it can be quite

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread rjp
On 03,Sep/01 8:30 pm, you wrote: Just like to tell everybody at abcusers that I've just posted a complete ABC edition of Tielman Susato's Danserye at http://www.musicaviva.com/abc/tunes/susato-tielman/susato-1551.abc This file has cr terminated lines I have fixed it using the KDE binary

Re: [abcusers] Susato's Danseryes

2001-09-04 Thread John Chambers
RJP writes: | On 03,Sep/01 8:30 pm, you wrote: | Just like to tell everybody at abcusers that I've just posted a complete | ABC edition of Tielman Susato's Danserye at | http://www.musicaviva.com/abc/tunes/susato-tielman/susato-1551.abc | | This file has cr terminated lines I have