Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Andries Brouwer
On Fri, Feb 15, 2013 at 10:56:17PM -0600, Ben Scarborough wrote: On Feb 16, 2013 02:13, Andries Brouwer wrote: The fragment of text I showed was not from dialectology, but just from a novel written in Elfdalian. The symbols are meant to be those of ordinary orthography. Does that mean

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/15/2013 11:59 PM, Andries Brouwer wrote: On Fri, Feb 15, 2013 at 10:56:17PM -0600, Ben Scarborough wrote: On Feb 16, 2013 02:13, Andries Brouwer wrote: The fragment of text I showed was not from dialectology, but just from a novel written in Elfdalian. The symbols are meant to be those of

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
That would make it analogous in a way to German ß. The minute things show up in real orthographies the pressure to handle ALL CAPS exists. The question then is whether you'll find SJ or overlaid S/J. Or how a Swede would instinctively handle this, in the absence of an example of a

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Jukka K. Korpela
2013-02-16 11:38, Stephan Stiller wrote: (By the way, for those finding the German rule to write SS unsatisfactory: It's hard to come by an actual minimal pair. Example: Strauss vs. Strauß. Originally the same name, but two spellings make them two names that may need to be distinguished from

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
[...] an actual minimal pair. Example: Strauss vs. Strauß. Originally the same name, but two spellings make them two names that may need to be distinguished from each other. True for Wei{ß/ss} as well. Or a non-name example: Buße (repentance) vs Busse (buses). But then, non-name examples

German »ß« (was: s-j combination in Unicode?)

2013-02-16 Thread Otto Stolz
Hello, Am 16.02.2013 11:48, schrieb Stephan Stiller: Or a non-name example: Buße (repentance) vs Busse (buses). But then, non-name examples are far less likely to remain ambiguous in context. Years ago, I have seen with my own eyes, in a Swiss magazine (where they consistently replace “ß”

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Andries Brouwer
On Sat, Feb 16, 2013 at 12:22:08AM -0800, Asmus Freytag wrote: On 2/15/2013 11:59 PM, Andries Brouwer wrote: On Fri, Feb 15, 2013 at 10:56:17PM -0600, Ben Scarborough wrote: Does that mean there's also a capital S-J? Probably, in entirely capitalized text. At sentence start I see

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
Or a non-name example: Buße (repentance) vs Busse (buses). But then, non-name examples are far less likely to remain ambiguous in context. A reason why Jukka's original example – like most proper name examples – was better than mine is that it's truly minimal in that context will really not

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 1:38 AM, Stephan Stiller wrote: That would make it analogous in a way to German ß. The minute things show up in real orthographies the pressure to handle ALL CAPS exists. The question then is whether you'll find SJ or overlaid S/J. Or how a Swede would instinctively handle

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 7:04 AM, Andries Brouwer wrote: [BTW Is the fact that o-slash is not decomposed not entirely analogous to the fact that i is not decomposed? I would say that neither gives an indication of how symbols involving a combining dot or combining slash are handled in general.] Why don't

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 7:04 AM, Andries Brouwer wrote: I found Diauni.ttf at http://www.thesauruslex.com/typo/dialekt.htm (swedish) http://www.thesauruslex.com/typo/engdial.htm (english) It has landmålsalfabetet at E100-E197 (lower case only) and s-j at E19F, S-J at E1A5, with Y-ogonek, Å-ogonek,

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
It's hard to come by an actual minimal pair. MASSE - mass or measurements? See, not hard at all. [and] With the new orthography, ss vs. ß affects the pronunciation of the preceding vowel. It's irritating to see SS because you have to override that rule when you know that the word in

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
the issue is a bit different, as not focused on one letter While we're splitting hairs: Word- or larger-level all-caps /does/ normally make a one-letter difference. When we undo all-caps, one can /normally/ lowercase everything of the word except the first letter. The capitalization bit of

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 10:48 AM, Stephan Stiller wrote: the issue is a bit different, as not focused on one letter While we're splitting hairs: Word- or larger-level all-caps /does/ normally make a one-letter difference. When we undo all-caps, one can /normally/ lowercase everything of the word except

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Philippe Verdy
2013/2/16 Stephan Stiller stephan.stil...@gmail.com: Of course in my worldview, all-caps writing is deprecated :-) This is a presentation style which makes words more readable in some conditions, notably on plates displayed on roads (cities are extremely rarely written in lowercase, as this is

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Julian Bradfield
On 2013-02-16, Philippe Verdy verd...@wanadoo.fr wrote: 2013/2/16 Stephan Stiller stephan.stil...@gmail.com: Of course in my worldview, all-caps writing is deprecated :-) This is a presentation style which makes words more readable in some conditions, notably on plates displayed on roads

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 10:48 AM, Stephan Stiller wrote: the issue is a bit different, as not focused on one letter While we're splitting hairs: Word- or larger-level all-caps /does/ normally make a one-letter difference. When we undo all-caps, one can /normally/ lowercase everything of the word except

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Philippe Verdy
Another solution is also used: Capitals written as Big capitals, and lowercase written as small capitals (i.e. just a minor font size reduction). True lowercase letters are causing problems on road sign indicators on roads with high speed : they are hard to read and if the driver has to look at

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 12:06 PM, Philippe Verdy wrote: 2013/2/16 Stephan Stiller stephan.stil...@gmail.com: Of course in my worldview, all-caps writing is deprecated :-) This is a presentation style which makes words more readable in some conditions, notably on plates displayed on roads (cities are

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Stephan Stiller
from earlier: Otto Scholz Oops, sorry. Otto Stolz. And usually not totally sense-destroying to a human reader with context available. But these fallbacks allow clear misspelled words to appear, not just miscapitalized ones. That's huge. I'm all for a capital version of ß and other such

Re: s-j combination in Unicode?

2013-02-16 Thread Asmus Freytag
On 2/16/2013 9:55 PM, Stephan Stiller wrote: from earlier: Otto Scholz Oops, sorry. Otto Stolz. And usually not totally sense-destroying to a human reader with context available. But these fallbacks allow clear misspelled words to appear, not just miscapitalized ones. That's huge. I'm all

Re: German »ß«

2013-02-16 Thread Julian Bradfield
On 2013-02-17, Philippe Verdy verd...@wanadoo.fr wrote: True lowercase letters are causing problems on road sign indicators on roads with high speed : they are hard to read and if the driver has to look at them for one more second, he does not look at the road. AS I SAID, empirical evaluation