People tend not to give reasons for leaving a list. Sometimes it's because the number of messages from a particular list is more than they feel can deal with. A few people have left <ambit> in recent weeks, but not a large number. It is relatively unusual for this to happen in a short space of time, at least according to the pattern over the short life of the list (this month is the first anniversary of <ambit>). I can draw no particular inference from this though. A similar number of new people have joined the list in the last month or so.

All I would say is that online communities can be fragile. There are currently 127 people on the <ambit> list. Yet increasingly debate is restricted to a tiny minority. My experience from other lists is that when views become very polarised (as often happens in a time of conflict), the level of common interest in the community can seem to be reduced, leading people to question their continued involvement and support. I would ask that people bear this in mind - it seems that the more strident the voices on <ambit> become, the more the response from others is silence.

Chris

At 10:08 am +0100 23/10/02, simon fildes & katrina mcpherson wrote:
Did Beverley actually say that these people left because of the current
debate?

If they just left without stating a reason then that should be made clear
now. To imply otherwise is wrong and bad.


If they said they left because of the current debate then they obviously
have a head-in-the-sand approach to world politics. You can't have a list
like this without engaging with the wider social political context. The CCA
issue only serves to highlight this.

Beverley?

--
--------------------------------------------------------
Chris Byrne [EMAIL PROTECTED]
--------------------------------------------------------
New Media Scotland tel: +44 131 477 3774 P.O. Box 23434, Edinburgh EH7 5SZ fax: +44 131 477 3775
Scotland, UK http://www.mediascot.org
--------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------
a m b i t : networking media arts in scotland
post: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
archive: http://www.mediascot.org/ambit
info: send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
and write "info ambit" in the message body
-------------------------------------------------
      • Re:... mark lawton
        • ... Karen J Guthrie
          • ... mark lawton
            • ... Karen J Guthrie
          • ... Beverley Hood
    • Re: <... Joseph Sergej Velez aka His Cigar Smoke Was Unmissably Subtle
      • Re:... mark lawton
      • <... torsten lauschmann
        • ... mark lawton
          • ... simon fildes & katrina mcpherson
            • ... Chris Byrne
              • ... mark lawton
              • ... Chris Byrne
              • ... mark lawton
              • ... Alice Angus
  • Fwd: Re: <... ambit admin

Reply via email to