On Sat, Mar 30, 2002 at 02:46:40AM -0500, John D. Giorgis wrote:

> You have merrily compared Israelis to Nazis.  Ordinarily making
> comparisions to Nazis is bad enough.  Comparing Jews to Nazis,
> however, is hateful to a measure beyond what I have words to describe.

John, I think this is unfair. I just don't see this hatred. If a person
hates, they want to see the hated one(s) hurt, embarrassed, put in their
place, killed, etc. I have not seen Jeroen expressing such feelings
about Israelis or Jews.

I do see lots of arguments from him that seem naive, have a lack of
relevant information, or display "logic" that is quite detached from
reality. But I just don't see this hatred you speak of. Don't confuse
fuzzy thinking and ignorance with malice.

> When confronted with this kind of hatred, I will happily attack this
> evil

Happily? Evil? I think accusing someone like that and then dropping out
of the discussion is not a responsible way to act. I'm not sure what
your goal is in acting like that. My goals in a discussion are usually
to try to persuade or educate others, or if I turn out to be mistaken,
to persuade or educate myself. Sometimes, neither one is possible, in
which case I just shut up when that becomes apparent. A parting attack
shot certainly isn't useful in that case.

-- 
"Erik Reuter" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>       http://www.erikreuter.com/

Reply via email to