> Ilana
> I can speak for myself only. And I, Ilana, already wrote you once, that
> *my* preferable solution is transferring all Palestinians that does not
> want to be full Israeli citizens to nearby Arab countries. (there are
> plenty of space in Sinai, Jordan, Saudia). According to last survey 46% of
> Israelis agree with me (it grew from 11% last year to 35% two month ago to
> 46% this Passover) on the other hand we have "The Seventh Day" now.


First, a couple of minor caveats.

The Arabs (and Palestinians) have learned their lesson.  You aren't going the 
be able to force the resulting refugees across the boarders.  The neigboring 
states are not going to let them cross and facilitate a crime.  (Forced exile 
violates international law.)  Better plan on providing some reservations 
along the boarders with Jordan and Egypt.

Also, there is the issue of Palestinian claims to right-of-return that are 
not addressed by your plan.


I still have two problems with this idea.  One is more serious than the 
other. 

1) This sounds like a fig-leaf to cover a policy of ethnic cleansing.  Making 
Palestinians a deal they "can't refuse" is hardly a free choice.

2) There is an off chance that the Palestinans will call the bluff and accept 
citizenship _en masse_.   _Voila_, suddenly Israel has a Palestinian 
majority.  So much for a majority Jewish state and 100+ years of the modern 
Zionist project.

===

Note that there is no law against unilaterally *bestowing* Israeli 
citizenship on Palestinians in the Occupied Territories whether they want it 
or not.  However, see point #2 above.

Reply via email to