In einer eMail vom 01.11.2006 12:52:49 Westeurop=E4ische Normalzeit schreibt 
[EMAIL PROTECTED]: 

> I disagree. Let's call 'em 
> Box-With-A-Beam-Attached-And-Strings-Producing-Sound-Stretched-Across.
> 

Frank,

Organologists such as Curd Sachs use the term "Lute" ("Laute") for exactly 
this configuration. The Renaissance cittern, the English guitar, the Portuguese 
guitarra, the Spanish guitar, the mandolins (flat or bowl-backed) and, of 
course, the Renaissance lute, are all "Lutes" in this sense.

Perhaps it might help a little to think of instruments in tems of all horses 
being quadrupeds, but not all quadrupeds - not even all hoofed quadrupeds - 
being horses. (All citterns are "Lutes", but not all "Lutes" - not even all 
flat-backed "Lutes" - are citterns).

Cheers,
John D.

--

To get on or off this list see list information at
http://www.cs.dartmouth.edu/~wbc/lute-admin/index.html

Reply via email to