Hi Priss, > That is correct. I realize this is a lot to ask of everyone, but I'd > like to close this discussion by **EOD today**.
It's tough to make decisions with tight timelines. I want to support the Cosmo team in experimenting with a detail view that's a good fit for the web. I definitely don't think the web side needs to slavishly follow the desktop UI. I think it's helpful for users who are new to Chandler to have explicit text next to stamping icons, rather than just tooltips. Similarly, having Now/Later/Done expanded really helps with the sense of what the triage widget is for. I think there's a trade-off between the extra space this expansion requires and helping new users, it may well be that for the web UI expanding the text is the right way to go with this trade-off. I'm worried, though, that part of the stamping concept that I really like might be lost. In the "traditional" UI, all the stamps are always visible in a central location, so at a glance I can find out what semantics I've associated with the current item. With this accordion rendering of stamps, the sense of what your stamping options are is dramatically improved, but which stamps are chosen is harder to coalesce. On small screens some stamps may even be out of view. >From my perspective this design would really benefit from more than a day of broad group iteration. I don't like getting in the way of momentum around good ideas, but I think given the way this is framed (lets decide today), I'm saying -1. Sincerely, Jeffrey _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Open Source Applications Foundation "Design" mailing list http://lists.osafoundation.org/mailman/listinfo/design
