Sergiu Dumitriu wrote: > Anca Luca wrote: >> Sergiu Dumitriu wrote: >>> Vincent Massol wrote: >>>> Hi, >>>> >>>> Let's vote on how to handle the title behavior for the 2.0 final >>>> release so that we're all on the same page. >>> Here's what Mediawiki (on Wikipedia) does: >>> >>> - the document title is displayed using a h1 id=firstHeading >>> - the content allows using =titles=, which generate h1 >>> - by a natural process, contributors rarely use =titles= in documents >>> >>> So I continue to think that we should allow users to enter = titles, and >>> they should generate h1. There is no rule against a document having more >>> than one h1. Again, the document title is in the <title> element, not in >>> the <h1> element. >> true, and this means that we could have the title displayed in a page in >> anything (<div>), doesn't necessarily have to be semantic, since its >> semantic is >> given by its use in the <title>. Normally, from the semantic pov, we should >> leave it only in title, but it's just that we need to emphasize it for the >> user. >> >> Why would we put it in a h1 then? > > Because it is the best element for the task at hand. It still is a > title, so it deserves a heading element.
just thinking if it's ok to have the title of the page as a (html) semantic sibling of its (wiki) semantic children. Also, since the <title> is the title of the page, if the title is a <h1> it's also a child of itself (actually that would be true regardless of the markup we'd use for it...) Happy hacking, Anca > >>>> After talking to several people here's what I propose: >>>> >>>> 1) We remove the top level H1 only if the title compat flag is on and >>>> the title H1 is the same as the top level H1 >>>> 2) The compat flag is off by default in our distributions >>>> 3) We modify the Toucan and Albatross skins to display the title (same >>>> as Colibri) >>>> 4) We modify the Default XE XAR to have titles for all its pages (and >>>> remove the header 1 in page content) >>> What happens with dynamic titles? >>> >>>> This should cover both user upgrades and new behavior. Note that user >>>> custom skin will still work in most cases since they're not normally >>>> touching the contentview.vm file. > > _______________________________________________ devs mailing list [email protected] http://lists.xwiki.org/mailman/listinfo/devs
