I was really hoping this thread wouldn't develop this way, but since it
has, here's my 0.02.

*To the OP:* these are the Slim community forums, so (most/everyone)
here has already considered the question you are asking and plumped for
the SB/Duet.  To that extent, our feedback isn't unbiased or
independent.  We can tell you why we chose the way we did, and the
things that we like about the two systems, but we have our clear
preferences.  If you've asked the same question on the Sonos forums,
and I hope you have, you'll get the alternative view.  

For myself, when I was choosing between the two systems, I had a choice
between going with Sonos or picking the SB and upgrading my speakers. 
The cost of Sonos then was a huge factor as was the fact (at the time)
it didn't play FLAC format (open source/lossless codec) which I had
decided I wanted to use.  I also like configuring and fiddling with my
setup, and I have since very much brought into the Slim, opensource,
community driven approach.  I don't want a closed system - I want to be
able to configure the services I use and if something comes into the
program or player that I don't like, I want to be able to roll back to
an earlier version.

The best advice I can give is to work out if there are any dealbreakers
with either system.  If not, download Squeezecenter (which comes with a
free software player/emulator) and run it through your files.  Have a
play and see if you like the style/features.  If yes, buy an SB or
Duet, try it for 30 days, and if you don't like it, send it back and
buy the Sonos.  If Sonos offers a 30 day money back guarantee, you
could buy that and trial it instead.

[EMAIL PROTECTED] - I was one of those who was extremely critical of the way
you chose to approach and review the Duet.  Not worth going over in
detail, but not so much what you said, as the way you chose to respond
afterwards as rob53ben and jaffacake.  To that extent, you have to
accept a level of background suspicion here as to your motives.  I
think an acknowledgement that things could have been handled better
would go a long way to alieviating that concern.  That said, I haven't
seen anything recently that suggests to me you're trying to do anything
other than what you say - review side by side and in detail the two
systems. If these forums are as friendly and helpful as we always hold
them out to be, people here need to get over it and pitch in to answer
your questions and help you out.  

I think it was Robin that had a conversation with one of the Sonos
admins when this all kicked off and both of them agreed there's a
danger in taking this too seriously.  Some of the Sonos people feel
there's a history of Sim posters Sonos-bashing on their forums - not
recently but look at the archives and they may have a point.

We'll all read your review with interest, and my only advice (entirely
unsolicited) is that you'll catch more flies with honey than with
vinegar. ;-)


-- 
Siduhe
------------------------------------------------------------------------
Siduhe's Profile: http://forums.slimdevices.com/member.php?userid=723
View this thread: http://forums.slimdevices.com/showthread.php?t=47145

_______________________________________________
discuss mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.slimdevices.com/lists/listinfo/discuss

Reply via email to