Dean Grannes wrote:
>> My only complaint with the Optima case... was the removal of the
>> rounded cutouts in the top case on the long edge between the cells.
>> [They allowed access to the bolts that bolted the battery down.
>>  _________  _________ 
>> /         \/         \
>> |         ||         |
>>  )       (  )       ( 
>> | BATT #1 || BATT #2 |
>> |         ||         |
>>  )       (  )       ( 
>> |         ||         |
>> \_________/\_________/

Yes, I liked that feature, too. It was removed years ago. But, there is
nothing in that area of the cover; the seal between cover and case
follows the cell wall. On the batteries I have, you could drill a hole
right through that area of the cover and not hit anything or cause a
leak. A long bolt could go thru these holes and into the bottom of the
battery box to secure them.

Note: this is only true for models without side posts; the side posts
prevent drilling into this area on one side.

Joe Smalley wrote:
> I think the best way to tie them down would be in the intercell area
> where your fingers go when picking up a six pack.
>  ________  ________
> /        \/        \
> |        ||        |
>  )  <>  (  )  <>  (
> | BATT 1 || BATT 2 |
> |        ||        |
>  )  <>  (  )  <>  (
> |        ||        |
> \________/\________/

(I.e. the <> in Joe's drawing above)

But, there is no hole in these locations. The <> near the positive
terminal can be drilled and used. But the one near the negative terminal
has an inter-cell jumper going through it -- you can't drill there!

> If the battery were tied down with two half inch through bolts with
> large washers or plates from above... the battery could sustain many
> more Gs of crash impact without coming loose

This reminds me of another concern.

Suppose you have a battery box full of Optimas. The battery hold-downs
mainly apply vertical clamping force, i.e. the batteries can slide
horizontally a little bit if forced. And suppose you slam on the brakes
or corner very hard, so as to generate a substantial horizontal force. 

The yellow lid is less than 1/2" thick. The entire side load is being
borne by that narrow edge. If the cornering or braking force is (let's
say) 1G, and there are 6 batteries in a row, then that edge is seeing 6
x 45 lbs = 270 lbs.

But that top is pretty thin. The top I have removed will buckle in half
with even half that load. That means such a load will put tremendous
force on the seal, as the lid tries to buckle and pop off.

So... do you need to securely mount every battery, so it can't slide
into its neighbor? Or do you put some kind of spacer between batteries,
so the load is spread across the entire sides?
-- 
Lee A. Hart                Ring the bells that still can ring
814 8th Ave. N.            Forget your perfect offering
Sartell, MN 56377 USA      There is a crack in everything
leeahart_at_earthlink.net  That's how the light gets in - Leonard Cohen

Reply via email to