On 30 Oct 2008, at 23:58, Brent Meeker wrote:
> Kory Heath wrote:
>> On Oct 30, 2008, at 10:06 AM, Bruno Marchal wrote:
>>> But ok, perhaps I have make some progress lately, and I will answer
>>> that the probability remains invariant for that too. The probability
>>> remains equal to 1/2 in the imperfect duplication (assuming 1/2 is
>>> the perfect one).
>>> But of course you have to accept that if a simple teleportation is
>>> done imperfectly (without duplication), but without killing you, the
>>> probability of surviving is one (despite you get blind, deaf,
>>> amnesic and paralytic, for example).
>> This is the position I was arguing against in my earlier post. Let's
>> stick with simple teleportation, without duplication. If the data is
>> scrambled so much that the thing that ends up on the other side is
>> just a puddle of goo, then my probability of surviving the
>> teleportation is 0%. It's functionally equivalent to just killing me
>> at the first teleporter and not sending any data over. (Do you
>> If the probability of me surviving when an imperfect copy is made is
>> still 100%, then there's some point of "imperfection" at which my
>> chances of surviving suddenly shift from 100% to 0%. This change will
>> be marked by (say) the difference of a single molecule (or bit of
>> data, or whatever). I don't see how that can be correct.
>> -- Kory
> But there are many ways for what comes out of the teleporter to
> *not* be you.
> Most of them are "puddles of goo", but some of them are copies of
> Bruno or
> imperfect copies of me or people who never existed before.
> Suppose it's a copy of you as you were last year - is it 100% you.
> It's not
> 100% the you that went into the machine - but if you're the same
> person you were
> last year it's 100% you. Of course the point is that you're not the
> same "you"
> from moment to moment in the sense of strict identity of information
> down to the
> molecular level, or even the neuron level.
Yes. And if a teleporter transforms me into a copy of me as I was last
year, I will say that although I have 100% survive, I suffer from an
amnesia bearing on one year of experience, and indeed I will have to
relearn what "I" have done and update myself accordingly.
I can complain about the doctor or about the teleportation company of
course, like someone who did survive a train accident, with injuries,
perhaps amnesia, can complain about the railroad society (if he
remembers the name).
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at