Note also that, by being universal machine, our look-up table are 


Le 18-mai-09, à 03:11, Kelly Harmon a écrit :

> On Fri, May 15, 2009 at 12:32 AM, Jesse Mazer <> 
> wrote:
>> I don't have a problem with the idea that a giant lookup table is 
>> just a
>> sort of "zombie", since after all the way you'd create a lookup table 
>> for a
>> given algorithmic mind would be to run a huge series of actual 
>> simulations
>> of that mind with all possible inputs, creating a huge archive of
>> "recordings" so that later if anyone supplies the lookup table with a 
>> given
>> input, the table just looks up the recording of the occasion in which 
>> the
>> original simulated mind was supplied with that exact input in the 
>> past, and
>> plays it back. Why should merely replaying a recording of something 
>> that
>> happened to a simulated observer in the past contribute to the 
>> measure of
>> that observer-moment? I don't believe that playing a videotape of me 
>> being
>> happy or sad in the past will increase the measure of happy or sad
>> observer-moments involving me, after all. And Olympia seems to be 
>> somewhat
>> similar to a lookup table in that the only way to construct "her" 
>> would be
>> to have already run the regular Turing machine program that she is 
>> supposed
>> to emulate, so that you know in advance the order that the Turing 
>> machine's
>> read/write head visits different cells, and then you can rearrange the
>> positions of those cells so Olympia will visit them in the correct 
>> order
>> just by going from one cell to the next in line over and over again.
> What if you used a lookup table for only a single neuron in a computer
> simulation of a brain?  So actual calculations for the rest of the
> brain's neurons are performed, but this single neuron just does
> lookups into a table of pre-calculated outputs.  Would consciousness
> still be produced in this case?
> What if you then re-ran the simulation with 10 neurons doing lookups,
> but calculations still being executed for the rest of the simulated
> brain?  Still consciousness is produced?
> What if 10% of the neurons are implemented using lookup tables?  50%?
> 90%?  How about all except 1 neuron is implemented via lookup tables,
> but that 1 neuron's outputs are still calculated from inputs?
> At what point does the simulation become a zombie?
> >

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at

Reply via email to