They also sell cars to anybody.....and look at the drivers out there. They also 
sell violins to anybody.

A tool is a tool. If a publishing house lets complete crap out, you should tell 
them that by returning that crap. If a "composer" comes in with a piece, and 
its totally NOT readable, then you should tell them that. Point out what needs 
to be fixed. For YEARS I sucked at writing out rhythm section parts, 
particularly DRUM charts. I ASKED everyone who played my stuff what I can do 
better, and they tell me what is good or bad about the music. And I fix it. My 
parts now are damn good if I do say so, but it's because I've worked at it. 
I've honed the tool (Finale) to produce legible music.

Again, while Daniel has a nice blog post about these intellectual pursuits, 
like positioning rests, I think people are better served by just seeing how it 
should look in a score example and then doing it that way. I NEVER rely on 
Finale or Sibelius to do the right thing. Ever. If I don't know how to notate 
something, I go look for how to do it. If it is two lines on the same staff, 
and how to do the rests, I go look for examples of it. And then decide what 
looks readable/legible to me and do it that way.

I can't tell you how many times I go to a rehearsal, and some old band teacher 
brings in a chart they did on Finale or Sibelius that is just a massacre. 3 
pages longer than it needed to be. Spacing all weird. DS in the wrong place. 
Dynamics on some parts but not others. Rehearsal marks wrong. Measure numbers 
off. I just want to scream.

Oh, last time I checked, major publishers didn't just "publish" scores. Even if 
you had a finale or sibelius file, you had to send them the score (printed) and 
then they would redo it in house in their style. This might have changed, but 
it used to be the practice of how one big name publisher used to do it (even 
though they used Finale as well).


NOT sent from a plane
--

On Feb 20, 2014, at 11:43 AM, Craig Parmerlee <[email protected]> wrote:

> And here is Daniel Spreadbury's latest diary entry:
> 
> http://blog.steinberg.net/2014/02/development-diary-part-the-fifth/
> 
> I really appreciate the things he is discussing.  I play in a symphony 
> orchestra that does 5 subscription concerts a year.  In 2 of the last 4 
> concerts we were given music that was so horribly notated that it could 
> not be played well in the first reading by musicians of any caliber, 
> IMHO.  I was so angered by this inept notation that I rewrote many of 
> the more tedious parts for the musicians.  At the second reading, the 
> music worked fine.
> 
> As the saying goes, "They will sell a Finale license to anybody". These 
> were not bad compositions.  And I am certain the composers were 
> excellent musicians.  But their notation was terrible, yet two different 
> publishing houses let these pieces go out the door. It is embarrassing 
> to musicians to get tripped up by incompetent copyists.  That's a 
> hangin' offense in my book.
> 
> I don't hold out much hope that publishers will recognize the error of 
> their ways and insist that competent copyists be engaged.  Indeed, the 
> reality is probably the opposite -- that publishers are likely to be 
> willing to accept crappier and crappier scores.  So to the extent that 
> notation programs will do a better job of encouraging best practices in 
> the future, I am all for that.
> 
> I must say that the second half of Spreadbury's article dealing with how 
> to jam two utterly incompatible musical lines onto one staff proves the 
> point.  None of his examples ever have any business being on a shared 
> staff if played by two different musicians.  IMHO, the only time it is 
> acceptable to double- or triple-up parts is when: a) they all have 
> parallel motion, b) there are never any overlapping notes (other than a 
> clearly marked (A2) section, and c) there is never any ambiguity 
> whatsoever about which accidentals belong to which notes. (One of the 
> worst cases is where a low G is flatted in part 3, and an octave-higher 
> G appears later in the measure for part 1 and the flat is not shown -- 
> as if player 1 is supposed to be reading all three parts.) This all 
> comes down to the issue, do you want musicians to play the music 
> correctly or don't you?  If you want the music played correctly, then 
> notate it correctly.
> 
> Sorry about the rant, but this stuff really sets me off sometimes.



_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to