Craig, you make an excellent point. But as a composer, it is nearly impossible 
to be confident that our manuscripts are what 
musicians are comfortable with.  There is lacking, imo, the interface between 
the good composer, and the musicians, when it
comes to the manuscript.

It would be greatly appreciated by some if we, as composers, were treated as a 
partner in a creative process, more than willing
to make adjustments, particularly to scores, as they may be pointed out to us.  

So, who in your orchestras, is responsible for making sure that the manuscripts 
are readably clear BEFORE you get the parts
and your are trapped into a schedule to performance?  If is is new work, not 
only is the composition new, but the manuscripts are
too.  It is the musician that has to be pleased, and it is not always possible 
for a composers to have their work reviewed by every
instrument player.

Orchestras, or at least an assigned member of the orchestra, could be of great 
service in furthering new music by engaging is the process of notation of the 
piece.  Just get the manuscript early and notify the composer of problem areas 
in time for them to be happily corrected.

thanks,

tim



On Feb 20, 2014, at 2:43 PM, Craig Parmerlee wrote:

> These 
> were not bad compositions.  And I am certain the composers were 
> excellent musicians.  But their notation was terrible,



_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to