On 2/20/2014 3:21 PM, timothy.price wrote:
> Craig, you make an excellent point. But as a composer, it is nearly
> impossible to be confident that our manuscripts are what musicians
> are comfortable with.  There is lacking, imo, the interface between
> the good composer, and the musicians, when it comes to the
> manuscript.

But aren't composers musicians?  Shouldn't they know what a readable 
part looks like?  Isn't that part of their education?

[snip]
>
> So, who in your orchestras, is responsible for making sure that the
> manuscripts are readably clear BEFORE you get the parts and your are
> trapped into a schedule to performance?  If is is new work, not only
> is the composition new, but the manuscripts are too.  It is the
> musician that has to be pleased, and it is not always possible for a
> composers to have their work reviewed by every instrument player.

But good notation is good notation -- if you can't read what you wrote 
then it's not good notation.  And if you are able to sit down with an 
instrument and play the parts, then you should know whether it's clearly 
written or not.

>
> Orchestras, or at least an assigned member of the orchestra, could be
> of great service in furthering new music by engaging is the process
> of notation of the piece.  Just get the manuscript early and notify
> the composer of problem areas in time for them to be happily
> corrected.
>

But the orchestras are paying for this music, aren't they?  The 
compositions which Craig complained about were published, thus money 
changed hands.  The performers should not be the beta-testers for the 
playability of the music.  Any more than we Finale users are happy being 
the unpaid beta-testers for the software.

It is the job of a composer to know what good notation is like -- there 
is no shortage of books which discuss notation (Elaine Gould's is a very 
comprehensive book and costly but there are many others which cost less).

I think it's very commendable that you will be willing to change your 
printed parts and score to make them more readable, but a publisher, 
once the music is printed, very rarely will change anything at all.

And with the prices that many publishers charge for orchestral music, 
especially rental music for which they have often had the notation 
errors pointed out but refuse to repair the problems, the end-user is 
under no obligation to do the composer's/publisher's work for them.


-- 
David H. Bailey
[email protected]
http://www.davidbaileymusicstudio.com

_______________________________________________
Finale mailing list
[email protected]
http://lists.shsu.edu/mailman/listinfo/finale

Reply via email to